StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Emotional Development in the Context of Conflict by Dehon and Weems - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "Emotional Development in the Context of Conflict by Dehon and Weems" attempts to justify the hypothesis that interparental violence creates maternal depression which, in turn, impacts the development and emotional state of witnessing children…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.4% of users find it useful
Emotional Development in the Context of Conflict by Dehon and Weems
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Emotional Development in the Context of Conflict by Dehon and Weems"

?Running head: ARTICLE CRITIQUE Article Critique BY YOU YOUR SCHOOL INFO HERE HERE Article Critique In “Emotional Development in the Context of Conflict: The Indirect Effects of Interparental Violence on Children”, there are many strengths and weaknesses related to the study approach selected by the authors, Christopher Dehon and Carl F. Weems. The hypothesis of the study is that interparental violence, or violence that occurs between fathers and mothers, has an associated set of outcomes on children who are witness to this violence, causing them to either internalize or externalize either emotional or behavioral problems. Drawing on previous research studies showing this linkage, the article attempts to justify the hypothesis that interparental violence creates maternal depression which, in turn, impacts the development and emotional state of witnessing children. When coupled with dysfunctional parenting practices, it is hypothesized that children will either act aggressively or violently as a response to this violence or internalize problems, including such acts as self-defeating language or simply exhibiting characteristics that illustrate some form of self-defamation as a result of interparental violence. Using previous, existing studies on the phenomenon of interparental violence and its known correlation to childhood behavioral and emotional problems to serve as the foundation for study, the authors utilized a quantitative research approach that could measure responses statistically. To add further credibility to the study, several research instruments were utilized, including what is referred to as the Conflict Tactics Scale, an instrument which provided numerical data results associated with the frequency of violence occurring with both the mothers of children and requesting responses from youths who may or may not have witnessed interparental violence. A total of 359 women, including a large comparison sample, a group of women currently housed in shelters for battered women, and those with a known history of spousal violence. This approach added more credibility to the research study, as it provided a balanced sampling method that did not, solely, focus only on women with a history of interparental violence. It is the goal of researchers to remain completely unbiased and approach their research efforts with a reflective and unprejudiced viewpoint. The article critiqued illustrates impartiality that is absolutely required of competent researchers by selecting a diverse sample. Furthermore, the sample also included 359 children, one child selected for each recruited woman in the study, providing opportunities for children either stemming from high violence environments, limited violence environments, or no violence environments to further exemplify that internalized and externalized behavioral and emotional problems may not necessarily be caused solely by witnessing violence between parental figures. Again, this illustrates the impartiality of the researchers, making this study much more convincing and reliable. If the authors had chosen samples that included only children who have witnessed abuse, it would have limited the aforementioned credibility currently sustained by the article and not served as a well-justified quantitative approach to research. The research study managed, additionally, to utilize the appropriate instruments to measure not only historical beliefs regarding the impact of interparental violence, but additional factors such as maternal depression which would either justify or refute previous studies that served as the foundation for the approach to this research effort. This instrument, referred to in the study as the Brief Symptom Inventory, consisted of 53 different self-reporting questions on a scale between zero and four to measure the potential impact of maternal depression symptoms. This approach, to support further competency of the researchers, would assist in correlating the responses of children who had either been witnesses to interparental violence or not said witnesses to determine whether maternal depression could theoretically play a role in how children internalize or externalize their problems caused by this spousal violence. It was necessary for this study, based on previous research results from others in the research community and the model utilized to build a hypothesis, to measure the potential impact of maladaptive and incompetent parenting skills. Since it was proposed in the study’s introduction that such maladaptive parenting behaviors were believed to be linked to children externalizing or internalizing their problems, measurement of this phenomenon was crucial to justifying or refuting the given model showing the linkage between violence, maternal depression and simply poor parenting skills. It is the responsibility of researchers attempting to justify a hypothesis to include all possible measurements for all variables and phenomenon. This research study was extremely adept in finding adequate methodologies that could create a statistical set of results to ensure the study sustained validity. The authors did not leave out crucial measurement, which served as a credit to the competency of the researchers. Though this research study largely justified that there is often a direct linkage between maladaptive parenting skills, maternal depression and the development of problem behaviors with children, the study also indicated there could be indirect correlations for each phenomenon measured in the study (Dehon & Weems, 2009). The authors attempt to explain away certain discrepancies between the chosen model showing direct linkage to child outcomes by suggesting there could be genetic factors. The data gleaned through the statistical analysis, such as the chi-squared test and the root mean square error of approximation (RMSEA), indicated that a more appropriate model showing direct and indirect linkages to child outcomes might be required, thus changing the dynamics of the given model used as a foundation for research approach. This is something expected of genuine and competent researchers: to remain neutral and simply report on findings with a detached and balanced method of analysis. Though this particular research study, in practical reality, did not provide much to the research community or the general public about how to effectively build models showing the linkages (or potential linkages) to child problem behaviors, it did provide support that there are absolutely correlations between interparental violence, maternal depression and how the child decides to internalize or externalize their problem attitudes and behaviors. In personal reflection, the authors accomplished their purpose, lending support for their original hypothesis and also creating a proverbial food for thought regarding the hindrances of interparental violence. Children who are exposed to interparental violence are known to be at greater risk for social, academic and general behavioral problems (Rossman, Hughes & Rosenberg, 2000). As such, this study added credence, in the student’s perspective, to advancing knowledge of the drivers for maladaptive childhood behaviors that could assist, in the future, toward creating a model of best practice in parenting and child protectionism. References Dehon, C. & Weems, C.F. (2009). Emotional Development in the Context of Conflict: The Indirect Effects of Interparental Violence on Children, Journal of Child and Family Studies, 19, pp.287-297. Rossman, B.R., Hughes, H.M. & Rosenberg, M.S. (2000). Children in Violent Families: The Impact of Exposure. Washington: Taylor and Francis. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Development Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words”, n.d.)
Development Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/psychology/1490126-development
(Development Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
Development Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words. https://studentshare.org/psychology/1490126-development.
“Development Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/psychology/1490126-development.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Emotional Development in the Context of Conflict by Dehon and Weems

Key Developmental Changes

This paper will address changes in respect to the above five aspects, which occur in a 14-year-old female that can be considered as deviations from normal development.... This paper will address changes in respect to the above five aspects, which occur in a 14-year-old female that can be considered as deviations from normal development.... More specifically, the paper will look into deviations from normal development and the legal, ethical, and procedural responsibilities of a community worker in such a situation....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Harsh Parenting during Adolescence

Adolescence is a transition within human development that affects mental and physical growth.... (Abbassi) A human being changes significantly during adolescence, especially concerning emotional, attitudinal, cognitive, and physical perspectives.... To exert their influence, parents may resort to physical and emotional coercion (Kelley).... This aggression may be emotional or physical and may continue throughout an adult's life unabated (Pedersen)....
8 Pages (2000 words) Research Paper

My Interactions with the Jesuit values

When the human personality is not amply mature and had not attained the ripeness ushered in by continual and persistent contemplation and education, the heart and the mind tend to be in a state a conflict.... I realized that the purpose of human existence and education is to aspire for a holistic development, the kind of evolution where the aspirations of the heart are shaped and molded by the discipline and formality emanating from the mind.... It is in the divine unity of the mental and emotional faculties that lies the true future of humanity and mankind....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Focus on Primary and Secondary Prevention in Depression

Children with major depressive episodes are also more prone to the development of conduct disorder, in which they maintain a recurring and persistent pattern of negative behaviours that fail to respect the rights of other members of society; a type of antisocial attitude.... This paper examines the literature on primary and secondary prevention of child depression, evaluating the strengths and weaknesses of individual studies as well as the field of psychiatry as a whole....
19 Pages (4750 words) Research Paper

Comparing and Contrasting Goethes Faust and Charlie Danielss the Devil Went Down to Georgia

The paper "Comparing and Contrasting Goethes Faust and Charlie Daniels's the Devil Went Down to Georgia" discusses that Faust is about a man who was tempted by the devil, though in a more profound way.... The song is somewhat more straightforward than Faust whose plot is much more complex.... ... ...
12 Pages (3000 words) Research Paper

Harsh Parenting during Adolescence

This literature review "Harsh Parenting during Adolescence" discusses adolescence as a transition within human development that affects mental and physical growth.... A human being changes significantly during adolescence especially in reference to emotional, attitudinal, cognitive, and physical perspectives.... In order to exert their influence, parents may resort to physical and emotional coercion.... This aggression may be emotional or physical and may continue throughout an adult's life unabated....
8 Pages (2000 words) Literature review

Advantages and Disadvantages of Deontology and Discourse Ethics

Use these approaches to evaluate how they could be used by the manager in making a decision as to whether BASF should go ahead with building the factory at Beaufort Country Park. ... ... he case explains a.... ... ... The paper 'Advantages and Disadvantages of Deontology and Discourse Ethics' is a creative example of the philosophy case study....
12 Pages (3000 words) Case Study

Models of Casework Intervention

The short-term, task-centered approach in social work believed in the capacity of people to make rational choices and achieve goals they have chosen themselves thus helpful in resolving interpersonal conflict, dissatisfaction in social relations, problems of social transition, reactive emotional distress, behavioral problems, and others (Thomas & Woods, p....
7 Pages (1750 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us