StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Brain Death and Cultural Competence - Case Study Example

Cite this document
Summary
The author of the paper "Brain Death and Cultural Competence" will begin with the statement that Mr. Ahmed, who comes from a Shite Muslim Arab-American family, suffered a massive heart attack, and as a result, his brain activity is reduced to marginal. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.9% of users find it useful
Brain Death and Cultural Competence
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Brain Death and Cultural Competence"

Brain Death and Cultural Competence Identification of salient facts Mr. Ahmed, who comes from a Shite Muslim Arab-American family, suffered a massive heart attack, and as a result, his brain activity is reduced to marginal. He is now in an Intensive Care Unit of the local community hospital and could breathe only with the assistance of a ventilator. Dr. Linda Hopkins, his treating physician, suggested the family to think on withdrawing the ventilator support, because Mr. Ahmed’s brain damage is irreversible. Nevertheless, Mr. Ahmed’s family member insisted on keeping the ventilator support. The doctor knew that the odds are against Mr. Ahmed. It is not possible to cure Mr. Ahmed. Under these circumstances, Nurse Janet Simpson suggested the family members to talk with Dr. Hopkins and the staff Imam from pastoral care sitting in a conference room. The Imam explained to Doctor Hopkins that according to their religious belief, cessation of brain activity is not considered as death of a human being. At the same time, the Imam explained the family members that according to the medical staff, very soon Mr. Ahmed’s brain would cease functioning. It would be considered as death, even though cardiovascular system might still function. As time passed, Mr. Ahmed became a brain dead person. Dr. Hopkins again approached the family with the same request, to turn off the ventilator. However, family members did not agree to it, and Nurse Simpson also reminded Dr. Hopkins about what the Imam said. Dr. Hopkins was in a quandary. She answered the Nurse; “By the death, we mean brain death and that is the law”. 2. Identification of Ethical Issues Shite religious beliefs do not consider that the cessation of brain activity is death of a human being. This is Mr. Ahmed’s familys religious belief. This is client’s autonomy. This is client’s family’s autonomy. Dr. Hopkins, as a physician understands that she has to fulfill her medical duty by turning off the ventilator, because the patient is a brain dead person. This is Dr. Hopkins autonomy as a physician. She cannot exercise this autonomy. Her act may be classified as malfeasance, or considered to be against the beneficences to Mr. Ahmed and his family. 3. Statement of Ethical Dilemma The dilemma is a situation in which the choices of one of two opposing decisions are equally difficult. Dr. Hopkins choice is to turn off the ventilator or stay with the Shite religious belief. She understands that Mr. Ahmed medically is a dead person. Keeping the ventilator on she cannot perform a miracle. At the same time, she understands she has to follow Shite Muslim cultural tradition. Dr. Hopkins is facing an ethical dilemma. An ethical dilemma is a state of moral choice, when one, no less important, destroys the realization of another moral value. Mr. Ahmeds family is also facing an ethical dilemma. There was a long pause among Mr. Ahmed’s family members, after the Imam explained that Mr. Ahmed would be considered dead, once the brain ceased functioning even though heart and lungs might function. This indicates that Mr. Ahmed’s family is also facing an ethical dilemma. When the family failed to resolve the dilemma among them, they referred to Mr. Ahmed saying, «He would say that we should keep trying.” This put additional pressure on Dr. Hopkins. As a doctor she fully understood that Mr. Ahmed would not make decision live years and years under ventilation support in an Intensive Care unit, but she could not prove it. She understood that by turning off the ventilator support, she would violet Mr. Ahmed’s autonomy. 4. Analysis according to Principles – including statement of recommendations for ethical resolutions. In assessing the conflict from the ethical point of view, one needs to identify all involved parties, and analyze the situation for a period of space of time. The issue here is to keep the ventilator support on, therefore, not violate Mr. Ahmed’s and his family’s autonomy and show beneficence to them. Let us analyze this situation from the view of all other present and prospective patients of the hospital. Mr. Ahmed is getting treatment in a local community hospital. Community hospital is paying for the treatment from their budget. Medical staffs know well that Mr. Ahmed’s biomedical process is irreversible. There is no way medical staffs can show beneficence to Mr. Ahmed, irrespective of whatever medical and human resources the hospital spends. The use of limited monetary fund will be a waste, if to consider that the same resources could be used for other patients, those who will recover. So what weighs more, showing beneficence to the family of a brain dead person or to the present and prospective patients? The local community medical staffs are facing an ethical dilemma. This is a professional ethical than a personal dilemma. When ethical dilemma is in the context of professional activities, one need to get the answer thru professional codes of ethics. 5. Counter argument entertained and refuted Ethical dilemmas arise every day, but, as a rule, we decide to use «the principle of least resistance». Local community medical staffs are questioning about spending their limited resources on a brain dead person. The medical staffs are not paying attention to malfeasance. Local community staff and Dr. Linda Hopkins are speaking of using professional ethic codes. However, a situation should not be excluded, when the postulates written in the professional conduct code, may conflict with some of the principles of universal ethics, regardless of one’s professional affiliation. The situation may be complicated by internal moral conflict, because every man has a set of moral criteria, which are valuable, but may be contrary to the prevailing rules and the norms of professional ethics. We live in a multiracial, democratic society, and every member of the society has the same right towards his or her own religion. Shite Muslim religion belief does not consider termination of brain activity as death. What about paying respect to the religious belief of Shite Muslim community? There are other Shite Muslims in the community, who may not like Dr. Hopkins decision. How will they accept Dr. Linda Hopkins’ decision? This is true that, not a single professional code of ethics may consider, the diversity of situations, which a professional faces. A professional needs to resort to the norms of universal ethics, when faces a situation like this. The norms of universal ethics are justice. Professional ethic codes are part of the justice too. However, in this case professional ethic codes cannot answer about how to resolve a medical issue by not hurting someone’s religious faith. What should the local hospital community staffs, and especially Dr. Linda Hopkins do to solve the ethical dilemma? Neither Dr. Linda Hopkins, nor the local community medical staffs can solve this ethical issue by using the ethical code only. The solution of this problem should be found thru the justice system, if Mr. Ahmed’s family opposed to turning off ventilation support. 6. Conclusion This case has two principal ethical issues; whether Dr. Linda Hopkins should turn off the ventilator against Mr. Ahmeds family members will and whether Mr. Ahmed’s family members should understand that a brain dead person would never recover. This section will analyze these issues to determine which ethical principles are at stake, how to resolve it giving the value to the weightiest principle. A physician’s responsibility is to provide proper treatment so the patient can recover. Mr. Ahmed is breathing on a ventilation support system. Ventilation support system is not a treatment method. Hospitals use it for a brief time, which will allow the out-of town relatives to get to the hospital and say goodbye. Is there any other treatment that medicine can offer to Mr. Ahmed? Mr. Ahmed is a brain dead person. As one cannot feed a dead person, so medicine cannot offer any treatment to Mr. Ahmed, once he is a brain dead person. Is Mr. Ahmed’s autonomy at stake? The answer is no. Is Mr. Ahmed’s family’s autonomy at stake? Mr. Ahmed’s family members autonomy is not at stake, but the medical option of turning of ventilation support contradicts their religious belief. Can we keep the ventilation support on forever, and if we do so, whose autonomy is mostly at stake? The other clients’ autonomy is at stake because hospital will not be able to use a part of their resources. Would Dr. Hopkins deprive Mr. Ahmed and his family of having beneficences by withdrawing the ventilation support? There is no unequivocal answer to this question. If we think the answer from the medical point of view, the answer is no. If we think the answer from a religious point of Shite Muslims belief, the answer is yes. However, here is one unequivocal answer. By keeping the support, Dr. Hopkins will deprive others of having beneficences. Because, a part of hospital medical and human resources will be engaged to support the ventilation, which will never, cure the patient. Dr Linda Hopkins’ act will be justified, for the greater interest and long-term outcome, if she turns off the ventilation system. However, there is one challenge. Will her performance be considered non-malfeasance and deliver justice to the Ahmed family? The above analysis cannot give that answer. That is why; it is recommended that Dr. Linda Hopkins seeks assistance of the justice system. Individuals leaving in a society seek the answer from the justice system, when other solution fails to satisfy the society. Justice system will be able to answer, whether turning the ventilation support off by Dr. Linda Hopkins is a non-malfeasance move towards Mr. Ahmed and his family members, whether it will harm the religious belief of Shite Muslims. This is the only way; we will find the solution of this dilemma. Uniform determination of death act of the United States of America says; “§ 1. [Determination of Death]. An individual who has sustained either (1) irreversible cessation of circulatory and respiratory functions, or (2) irreversible cessation of all functions of the entire brain, including the brain stem, is dead. A determination of death must be made in accordance with accepted medical standards.” On September 8, 1992, Justice MacKenzie, said at Michigan Appeal court "A person will be considered dead if in the announced opinion of a physician, based on ordinary standards of medical practice in the community, there is the irreversible cessation of spontaneous respiratory and circulatory functions. If artificial means of support preclude a determination that these functions have ceased, a person will be considered dead if in the announced opinion of a physician, based on ordinary standards of medical practice in the community, there is the irreversible cessation of spontaneous brain functions. Death will have occurred at the time when the relevant functions ceased." The above case study clearly shows that Dr Linda Hopkins’ decision of turning off the ventilation support system to Mr Ahmed, once he is declared brain dead, will not be wrong, and will not prevail against the religious belief of Shite Muslim in accordance with the existing law of the country. This act will deliver justice to all parties in a broad sense and for a long-term outcome. At the same time Mr. Ahmed’s family member should pay respect to the law of the country. References Death Defination. (n.d.). Legal Reference. Retrieved from http://www.duhaime.org/LegalDictionary/D/Death.aspx In re Rosebushm 491 NW 2d 633 – Mich: Court of Appeals 1992. (n.d.). Michigan Court of Appeals. Retrieved from http://scholar.google.ca/scholar_case?case=8098579616030293515&q=543+nw+2d+321&hl=en&as_sdt=2,5 Uniform Determination of Death Act. (n.d.). National Conference of Commissioners on Uniform State Laws. Retrieved from http://www.law.upenn.edu/bll/archives/ulc/fnact99/1980s/udda80.htm. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Case study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words - 5”, n.d.)
Case study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words - 5. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1595822-case-study
(Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words - 5)
Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words - 5. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1595822-case-study.
“Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words - 5”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1595822-case-study.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Brain Death and Cultural Competence

Study of Diego's Medical History

The paper "Study of Diego's Medical History" tells the Relevance of the Assessment Case in Handling Diego's Case.... Diego's history examination reveals that he has been having behavioural issues since he was a little boy.... He would cause chaos at school and become a bad influence on the family....
42 Pages (10500 words) Research Paper

Cultural Competence

This paper ''cultural competence'' tells us that The sphere of social care workers is diversely comprised.... hellip; Thus, in discharging the professional duties and accomplishing social tasks, social care workers need to work hard and develop adequate cultural competence.... In the course of cultural competence development, anti-racist practice must focus on the discriminations based on colour and race (Sue, 2006).... Describe one model of cultural competence and discuss the potential benefits and limitations of applying the model....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Maintenance of Social Hierarchie

Providing care to people in different cultural setting demand that health care providers must be culturally competent.... Therefore, every health care provider should be knowledgeable, aware, and skilful on different cultural issues.... Lack of cultural competency in provision of health care services can result to fatal outcomes caused by cultural misinterpretations.... cultural incompetency can also lead to poor self-esteem on both caregivers and health care consumers....
3 Pages (750 words) Admission/Application Essay

Cross Cultural Perspectives

You can bring the change about yourelf or it can come in way that give you little choice about it what, when, and how.... Fighting againt change can low it down or divert it, but it won't top it however.... If you wih to ucceed in thi rapidly changing new world "you mut learn to look on change a a friend - one who preent you with an opportunity for growth and improvement....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

Ethical Health Care

What de we think about the purpose of the cultural competence, it is to achieve improved health standards of minorities and ethnic groups.... This is components level, let us consider the second aspect of the cultural competence, that is "attitude" one should have will power and willingness to offer adapt selfless services to others needs when they are in distress or when they are in dire conditions ...
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

The Importance of Cultural Awareness and Tolerance in EMS

cultural competence enables EMS personnel to provide care to diverse populations.... cultural competence gives medical personnel the ability to interact with patients of varied cultures.... People values, experiences and cultural backgrounds lead them to do things in a certain way.... cultural awareness has been taunted as the foundation of communication because it involves stepping away from ones self ad becoming aware of cultural values, perceptions and beliefs....
12 Pages (3000 words) Term Paper

Resilience and Spirituality in the Military

The paper "Resilience and Spirituality in the Military" discusses that trustworthiness and loyalty, training, communication, education, innovation in a problem-solving, fast-paced environment, and well-traveled and life experience are the competencies required of effective resilience.... hellip; The very nature of military life, the very task of the military, and the very reason for the military's existence actually do not simply develop the nine core competencies for effective resilience but require them....
13 Pages (3250 words) Research Paper

Background of Diversity in Nursing

This occurred when white non-Hispanics dominated nursing programs and ethnic minorities were underrepresented in the nursing student body.... This… Patients from ethnic minorities, especially those that could not speak English, felt that white nurses did not understand them.... Beyond the nursing educational programs, the Immigration brought people from different cultures, ethnicities and races with unique medical needs from the ones that nurses were previously used to (Gooden et al....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us