StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Perspective on Reality TV - Literature review Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper 'Perspective on Reality TV' presents a critical examination of the arguments contained in both articles. First, a brief summary of the arguments for the usefulness of reality television to audiences as presented by Murray is given. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.7% of users find it useful

Extract of sample "Perspective on Reality TV"

Why Murray’s (2003) perspective on reality TV is no longer valid in the current times The phenomenon of reality television has been growing in popularity since its introduction. This popularity has been based on reality television’s ability to engage audiences at a human level – a quality which both cinema and traditional television programmes have failed to develop. Despite its popularity among consumers, there have been growing concerns about the extent to which reality television shows are real in terms of presentation and authenticity. Essentially, these two contradicting perspectives have been presented by Murray (2003) and Poniewozik (2006). This essay presents a critical examination of the arguments contained in both articles. First, a brief summary of the arguments for the usefulness of reality television to audiences as presented by Murray is given. This is done with reference to relevant literature on the value and importance of reality television shows to general audiences. Also, a brief summary of the contrasting perspectives towards reality television shows as presented by Peniewozik is presented. This is done in view of recent academic opinion about the effect of using different technical devices on the overall authenticity of reality television shows. Throughout the argument presented in this essay, it can be seen that when evaluated in comparison to the information presented in Poniewozik’s article, Murray’s perspectives towards reality television are of little validity in the current times. Murray (2003) argues that reality television should be viewed as something that is able to engage the audience at a human level, a thing that film and television in general failed to achieve. Further, the main reason why reality television is important in today’s entertainment industry arises from the failures of the film industry. According to Murray (2003), films have failed to make good stories despite the finding that goes into their production. This failure to make good stories can be attributed to the way films may have good scenes but still fail to convince the audience at the end of the story. What happens is that members of the audience are aware of the fact that all the scenes in the film are actually acted out as opposed to being the reality. Although reality television shows do have several technical failures that audiences are able to point out in the events, they remain a viable option of engaging the audience. Murray highlights several reasons for this. To begin with, reality television uses real characters as opposed to films which make use of actors. Murray states that in reality television, audiences are “are watching a real person be genuinely happy or sad”. This is in stark contrast to what happens in cinema and other television programmes which, as a result of using characters, fail to sensitise the audience on the emotional experiences that are depicted in the scenes. The second point that is presented in this article is that by watching real characters go through ordinary daily activities, reality television helps the audience sympathise with the participants. Murray (2003) observes that this is important since the audience is able to share in the emotional journey that the characters undergo. The perceptions about reality television offered by Murray are not new at all. Papacharissi and Mendelson (2007, p. 357) observe that the attraction of the audience towards reality television lies in the historical nature of participatory media. Ideally, participatory media started in the early 20th century with the beginning of publications that involved contributions from readers. This gave way to confessional women’s magazines that became popular in Australia and the US back in the 20th century (Papacharissi & Mendelson 2007, p. 359). In the current times, reality television shows derive their popularity from their ability to achieve two objectives: the desire to participate in television programming and to have a direct observation of the daily activities of ordinary people (Birressi & Nunn 2005, n.pag). This implies that with reality television, individuals not only have a direct participation in the programming but also enjoy watching ordinary individuals going about their ordinary day-to-day lives. On the other hand, it has been observed that reality television shows play a key role in shaping the cultural values of the society. For instance, Holmes and Jermyn (2004, p. 10), state that the demand for reality television shows arises from a deep seated need in individuals for real life experiences. This is because the current modern society is so dominated with digitalised and constructed products that individuals crave for products that depict the real. It is important to note from these observations that reality television has developed as a result of a growing demand in the market for real life experiences. It can be seen that the public has expressed a desire to access content that depicts ordinary events in an ordinary manner. This is in agreement with the main argument that is presented by Murray that reality television fills the void for two desires in individuals: direct participation and observation of ordinary lives. Much as reality television presents events that are supposed to be real and featuring ordinary people, the process of developing the shows exposes the footage and sounds collected to extensive editing. It is in the course of editing that producers use different techniques to alter different aspects of the shows. The result of this process is that the final product that gets to consumers in the form of reality television shows lacks in authenticity, form and truth. This is what Holmes and Jermyn (2004, p. 11) call the ability of reality television shows to “manipulate and construct the real”. According to Poniewozik (2006), reality television shows lack authenticity because of several reasons. To begin with, whereas the shows are supposed to cover ordinary events of ordinary people, the use of editors and other skilled writers means that the plot, sequence and the events that are presented in the shows are so altered that the process amounts to the entire shows being scripted. This means that through extensive editing, the authenticity of reality television shows is greatly compromised. The second point is that in subjecting the works to extensive editing, producers end up misrepresenting the participants (Poniewozik 2006). The corollary is that whereas reality television shows are meant to feature real people going through their daily lives, editing work ends up misrepresenting the intentions and real motives of the participants. The reason for this is that since consumers are in need of suspense, producers of reality television shows “…fabricate things about real people who have to carry their fake reputations into their real lives” (Poniewozik 2006). The third issue that Poniewozik points out about reality television shows concerns the different skills that producers and editors employ in producing the final product to the market. According to Poniewozik, the use of skills such as “frankenbiting, fake settings, misleading montage and overdub” amounts to manipulating the authenticity of reality television shows (2006). Also, when producers use leading interview and other skills, the overall effect is that reality television shows are compromised in terms of authenticity and truth (Magidson 2014, p. 30). This is so even if it is done to enhance the action and satisfy the curiosity of the audience, who are in need of suspense and drama. When the information presented by Poniewozik about reality television shows is used to re-evaluate the perspective of Murray, it can be seen that the latter’s position and perceptions about reality television are of little relevance in the current time. This can be confirmed by examining several features of reality television and comparing the perceptions of both Murray and Poniewozik about the features. To begin with, reality television shows are meant to represent real life events. Since their beginning, viewers were inclined to accept them at face value, taking what was offered as a real representation of actual events in the lives of ordinary people. To this score, Murray observes that reality television overcomes the difficulties of cinema by offering the audience a view into the lives of ordinary people (Murray 2003). However, it has been seen that with the growing discovery of the extent to which representation is used in the production of reality television shows, many users are beginning to consider the stories as quite unreal and untrue (Biressi & Nunn 2005, n.pag). Although Murray suggests that reality television is an authentic representation of life events, it can be seen that this is not the case. With specially built settings that are different from what goes on in the real world, reality television shows cannot be said to be truly authentic. In addition to this, the question of authenticity arises when one considers the kind of communication that takes place among participants in reality television shows. It has been pointed out that these shows depend on exploiting the emotional moments that participants find themselves in the course of the events. Through monologue, the emotional element of the events is presented to the viewers. Much as this may be necessary, its use can be interpreted to compromise the overall authenticity of the shows. Aslama and Pantti state: The power of the monologue in reality TV can be seen as a parallel to the fascination of the entire genre for its audiences. The monologue, as with reality programming in general, contains an ambiguous interplay of the pre-scripted and non-scripted, individual and collective, performed and non-performed and fake and real. Consequently, the thrill for viewers is to hunt for the few rare authentic moments when the participant seems to reveal their ‘real’ self. (Aslama & Pantti 2006, p. 181). The implication of this is that with the use of monologue, producers of reality television shows exercise their control over the material by presenting to viewers events that have already been scripted. Another issue that arises with regard to reality television shows concerns the use characters. Essentially, reality television shows are based on following the progress of characters over a period of time. Edwards (2013, p. 17) observes that it is the manner in which the participants are turned into characters with whom the audience identifies with that drives reality television shows. Their progress through self-disclosure and personal revelation is what provides for the drama that comes with reality television shows. Concerning characterisation, Murray states: A key ingredient of reality TV is the casting of “ordinary people”. No longer are audiences watching an actor pretend to be sad or happy. By and large, they are watching a real person be genuinely happy or sad. There is no performance to deconstruct. It is real. (Murray 2003) However, when one considers the actual way in which the participants in the shows are chosen, the validity of this statement is lost. The casting for the shows is modelled in such a way that producers look for individuals who fit into specific story lines that have been developed (Poniewozik 2006). This way, producers are able to, “tell a story clearly, quickly and entertainingly” (Poniewozik 2006). Also, the observation that reality television involves casting of “ordinary people” can be seen to be untrue when one considers that reality television shows often involve celebrities and other famous personalities in their casting. This implies that the participants who appear in the shows are not randomly chosen ordinary individuals but are rather a select group of individuals that are carefully chosen to fit into specific story lines. It can therefore be concluded that when examined with regard to the aforementioned issues, the perceptions of Murray about reality television can be found to be of little validity in the current times. In conclusion, it can be seen that when evaluated with regard to the information contained in Poniewozik’s (2006) article, Murray’s (2003) perspectives towards reality television are less relevant in the current times for the following reasons. First, Murray (2003) argues that reality television is useful in engaging with the audience at a human level. Although this is true when reality television is compared to cinema and other forms of television programming, the fact that reality television is subjected to technical processes that destroy its very nature of authenticity and reality means that this may not be necessarily so. Also, when examined under the element of character, setting, audience, representations and discourse, it can be seen that what reality television shows present to the audience are works that have been subjected to extensive editing careful selection of participants and enhanced storylines. Although all these processes are carried out in order to satisfy the needs of the consumers in the market, their overall effect is that the authenticity of reality television shows is greatly compromised. References Aslama, M & Pantti, M 2006, ‘Talking alone: reality TV, emotions and authenticity’, European Journal of Cultural Studies, vol. 9, no. 2, pp. 167–184, viewed 3 February 2014, Biressi, A & Nunn, H 2005, Reality TV: Realism and revelation, Columbia University Press, New York. Edwards, L H 2013, The triumph of reality TV: the revolution in American television, ABC-CLIO, California. Holmes, S & Jermyn, D 2004, ‘Introduction: understanding reality TV’, in Holmes, S & Jermyn, D (eds), Understanding Reality Television, pp. 1–32, Psychology Press, New York. Magidson, L A 2014, ‘Love is just a game in a mediated world: the representation of gender in The Bachelor and The Bachelorette’, Master’s Thesis, University of Witwatersrand, viewed 3 February 2014, Murray, S 2003, ‘The positives of reality’, The Age, October 16 2003, viewed 3 February 2014, Papacharissi, Z & Mendelson, A W 2007, ‘An exploratory study of reality appeal: uses and gratifications of reality TV shows’, Journal of Broadcasting & Electronic Media, vol. 51, no. 2, pp. 355–371, viewed 3 February 2014, Poniewozik, J 2006, ‘How reality TV fakes it’, Time Magazine, January 29 2006, viewed 3 February 2014, Read More

In the current times, reality television shows derive their popularity from their ability to achieve two objectives: the desire to participate in television programming and to have a direct observation of the daily activities of ordinary people (Birressi & Nunn 2005, n.pag). This implies that with reality television, individuals not only have a direct participation in the programming but also enjoy watching ordinary individuals going about their ordinary day-to-day lives. On the other hand, it has been observed that reality television shows play a key role in shaping the cultural values of the society.

For instance, Holmes and Jermyn (2004, p. 10), state that the demand for reality television shows arises from a deep seated need in individuals for real life experiences. This is because the current modern society is so dominated with digitalised and constructed products that individuals crave for products that depict the real. It is important to note from these observations that reality television has developed as a result of a growing demand in the market for real life experiences. It can be seen that the public has expressed a desire to access content that depicts ordinary events in an ordinary manner.

This is in agreement with the main argument that is presented by Murray that reality television fills the void for two desires in individuals: direct participation and observation of ordinary lives. Much as reality television presents events that are supposed to be real and featuring ordinary people, the process of developing the shows exposes the footage and sounds collected to extensive editing. It is in the course of editing that producers use different techniques to alter different aspects of the shows.

The result of this process is that the final product that gets to consumers in the form of reality television shows lacks in authenticity, form and truth. This is what Holmes and Jermyn (2004, p. 11) call the ability of reality television shows to “manipulate and construct the real”. According to Poniewozik (2006), reality television shows lack authenticity because of several reasons. To begin with, whereas the shows are supposed to cover ordinary events of ordinary people, the use of editors and other skilled writers means that the plot, sequence and the events that are presented in the shows are so altered that the process amounts to the entire shows being scripted.

This means that through extensive editing, the authenticity of reality television shows is greatly compromised. The second point is that in subjecting the works to extensive editing, producers end up misrepresenting the participants (Poniewozik 2006). The corollary is that whereas reality television shows are meant to feature real people going through their daily lives, editing work ends up misrepresenting the intentions and real motives of the participants. The reason for this is that since consumers are in need of suspense, producers of reality television shows “…fabricate things about real people who have to carry their fake reputations into their real lives” (Poniewozik 2006).

The third issue that Poniewozik points out about reality television shows concerns the different skills that producers and editors employ in producing the final product to the market. According to Poniewozik, the use of skills such as “frankenbiting, fake settings, misleading montage and overdub” amounts to manipulating the authenticity of reality television shows (2006). Also, when producers use leading interview and other skills, the overall effect is that reality television shows are compromised in terms of authenticity and truth (Magidson 2014, p. 30). This is so even if it is done to enhance the action and satisfy the curiosity of the audience, who are in need of suspense and drama.

When the information presented by Poniewozik about reality television shows is used to re-evaluate the perspective of Murray, it can be seen that the latter’s position and perceptions about reality television are of little relevance in the current time.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Perspective on Reality TV Literature review Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2000 words, n.d.)
Perspective on Reality TV Literature review Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2000 words. https://studentshare.org/media/2051407-murrayquots-2003-article-and-ponlewozikquots-from-2006-present-2-contrasting-perspectives-on-the
(Perspective on Reality TV Literature Review Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2000 Words)
Perspective on Reality TV Literature Review Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2000 Words. https://studentshare.org/media/2051407-murrayquots-2003-article-and-ponlewozikquots-from-2006-present-2-contrasting-perspectives-on-the.
“Perspective on Reality TV Literature Review Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2000 Words”. https://studentshare.org/media/2051407-murrayquots-2003-article-and-ponlewozikquots-from-2006-present-2-contrasting-perspectives-on-the.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Perspective on Reality TV

Make the Impossible Possible: The TV Program Strictly Come Dancing in the UK and China

This thesis provides a detailed analysis of the tv program Strictly Come Dancing that is featured in the UK and in China.... The tv show which features celebrity non dancer and professional dancers paired in a competing context has gained extreme popularity around the world and apart from the original British version, the show is now also adapted in more than 38 countries and features regional celebrities and professional dancers who compete on the tv program ....
38 Pages (9500 words) Thesis

Rating Takes Priority over Quality in Television Programming Provision

On one hand, tv has pleased, amazed, and horrified millions of viewers through the years.... On the contrary, some believe that tv is unreal, violent and something that should not be watched by kids.... The paper "Rating Takes Priority over Quality in Television Programming Provision" discusses that striking the right balance between quality and achieving high ratings is important, i....
8 Pages (2000 words) Coursework

Fluid Boundaries in Reality TV

he aim of the paper is to answer the question "How does reality tv construct the boundary between the ordinary and extraordinary?... reality tv creates a flexible and dynamic boundary,where the audience can hardly see the differences.... reality tv is supposed to be about 'real' people and their 'real' behaviours, but as the existence of the camera and the gaze of viewers and producers shape the 'realities' of reality tv show participants, the 'reality' of reality shows comes into question....
17 Pages (4250 words) Essay

Desensitization Of Audiences By Reality Television

It is virtually impossible to find a single channel that is not producing reality television shows.... The paper "Desensitization Of Audiences By reality Television" discusses the difference between reality and a stylized simulation of it and how it affects human sensibility.... reality television is not 'real' in the sense that many viewers believe it to be.... The traditional reality shows are separated into two distinct types, those that involve a goal, competition or prize to be earned, like Americas Next Top Model, Hell's Kitchen, or Survivor and the second form that simply and solely follow people through their daily lives for no other purpose than from the spectacle of watching their 'real' lives unfold as entertainment; this includes shows like Jersey Shore and any and all shows beginning with the words '....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Quantitative and Qualitative research into the voyeuristic appeal of watching observational reality TV

Since then, reality tv has increasingly exploded into the mainstream of television programs, and they are no longer.... bservational reality tv is about viewing developing factual television genre Mostly, it is assumed that the audience may not tell the difference between information and entertainment, or reality and fiction in popular factual television.... Therefore, in regards of the audience and reality tv it is significant to examine this genre's development and audience relationships with the popular factual output....
12 Pages (3000 words) Research Paper

Reality TV: the Bachelor

But whether this TV program is one that is based only on reality tv?... This paper "reality tv: the Bachelor" discusses the hit TV series, 'The Bachelor' as one that has continued to charm American audiences and has created a different understanding to marriage and those that are coupled in society.... Speaker 1 (psychoanalytic): When many looks at reality tv, specifically with a Bachelor, there is a belief that this is specifically linked to reality as it is portrayed in society....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

The Concept of Quality TV

This essay "The Concept of Quality tv" discusses the concept of Quality tv and how Quality tv shows, Mad Men in particular, problematize the issues of production/industry, audience/context and authorship.... Some other is of the view that quality or quality tv is the product of the interpretive community or professional community whose norms, ideals and methods determine an interpretation's validity (McCabe & Akass 145).... But later the advent of various channels and the various programs broadcasted earned them the name 'Quality tv'....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Reality TV in China

This paper ''reality tv in China'' tells that Globalization has been an essential component in the context of the 21st century.... The development of this report relates to the case study of format adaption concerning reality tv in the context of China.... reality tv refers to a television program, which is non-scripted involving real people doing diverse activities on camera.... Some of the types of reality tv shows include game shows, talent search, makeovers, and relevant issues....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us