StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Prosperity Without Growth - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This essay "Prosperity Without Growth" explains the impact of growth on prosperity in accordance with “Prosperity without growth”, a book by Professor Tim Jackson. It emphasizes the fact that “Prosperity without growth” is not only an alternative vision but also a necessity for our world…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.7% of users find it useful
Prosperity Without Growth
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Prosperity Without Growth"

? “PROSPERITY WITHOUT GROWTH” IS NOT ONLY AN ALTERNATIVE VISION BUT ALSO A NECESSITY FOR OUR WORLD This essay explains the impact of growth on prosperity in accord to “Prosperity without growth”, a book by Professor Tim Jackson. It emphasises on the fact that “Prosperity without growth” is not only an alternative vision but also a necessity for our world. The dominant view about growth is explained along with the factors, which cause the relentless phenomenon of growth that we have so far experienced. It explains why humanity should look towards prosperity, which is not going to be measured by the traditional indices of growth. TABLE OF CONTENTS Introduction 4 Limits To Growth 4 Mathematical Analysis 5 Role And Impact Of Technical Advancements 7 The Quality Of Life 7 Challenges 7 Transition To A Sustainable Economy 8 Conclusion 8 References 10 1. Introduction Barack Obama (27 March 2008) said, “I think all of us here today would acknowledge that we’ve lost that sense of shared prosperity”. With the escalating gap between the economy of nations and amongst the individuals of same nation, prosperity is declining. The definition of prosperity needs to be revisited considering the world’s limitation of resources. According to Jackson (2009), global economy is constrained by finite ecological limits. The flourishing of human society in context of ecological limits is not only an alternate vision but also a necessity. This is a finite world with limited resources. To add to this, the population is expected to rise to 9 billion [1] and even more within a span of just three decades. Having a vision of prosperity for such a scenario is the need of the hour. Jackson (2009) has scrutinized the assumption that whether growth is essential for prosperity or not. Herman Daly (2008) and others have continuously tried to put forward the notion of steady-state economy. Jackson’s Prosperity Without Growth (2009) has been a vital attempt on the same notion and following it there are considerable “De-growth” European movements (Latouche, 2007) and surfacing of organisations like CASSE (2010). These actions and notions are all in favour of removing the growth element from the current implications of the economy. The arguments against this idea constitutes primarily of the reforms of the consumer-capitalist society. However as per Trainer (2010), the consumer capitalist society cannot be fixed or reformed. Rather, it needs to be scrapped and then remade along different lines. 2. Limits to Growth There are some huge issues down the line and these include the complete consumption of the environment, resource depletion, war, conflicts and lessening of social bonding. The key cause behind this would be overconsumption. Fotopoulos (2007) comments on the “de-growth initiative” and states that people are currently trying to live at standards of affluence which are too high for all to share. This is leading to an unstable society and considering the environmental factors, the adversity of results can be well analysed. Considering the following two examples, it is clear that the there needs to be a limit set to the growth factor or else, there would be no prosperity at all. Example 1: As per World Wildlife Fund (2009), it takes around 8 hectares of potent land to supply water, food and settlement area for one individual in Australia. After three decades, considering the number of 9 billion, 72 billion hectares of potent land would be required. This is approximately 10 times of the land which would be available at that time. Example 2: The Green House issue is well addressed by Hansen (2008) and Meinschausen et al (2009). In order to discontinue carbon content present in the atmosphere, the CO2 eliminations would be required to be completely eliminated by possibly 2030. Such examples clearly explain that the rich people’s living standards would no longer be sustainable in the coming future. People are living in way which makes it completely impossible to share resources by all. 3. Mathematical Analysis According to Jackson (2009), a massive increase in resource use, considering global economy of 2050, the need of setting ecological limits becomes very important. Meadows et al (2004) explored the possible outcomes of exponential population rise, resource use and economic activity. As per the following figure, humans are clearly heading for a collapse as the ecosystem is exceeding its resource base. Figure 1: b) Ecological overshoot, a) Economic growth (Jackson, 2009) Meadows et al (2004) suggested that the scarcity of the resources would eventually bring about a rise in the prices and cease the possibility of growth in future. For the same reason, the resource base would eventually collapse if the material throughput is not curtailed. One of the key notions given by Meadows et al (2004) is that the amount of resources cannot be computed by taking into account the current reserves and dividing it by the current usage, if the resource use is increasing. In such a scenario, the resource usage would also be taken into account as a percentage increase annually. Consider the case of chromium whose reserves were 775 million metric tons (MMT) in 1972 from which 1.85 MMT was mined annually. *The static index comes to be 775/1.85=418 years. However, taking into account the constant rate of increase in increase in usage as 2.6%, (Meadows et al (2004),pp 54–71), the statistics would differ. Including the 2.6% rate of increase in consumption, the resources would instead last for: calculating formula for a resource’s time left with constant consumption growth is: [2] where: y = years left; r = 0.026, the continuous compounding growth rate (2.6%). s = R/C or static reserve. R = reserve; C = (annual) consumption. 4. Role And Impact Of Technical Advancements People generally follow an approach that even if it growth escalates to high levels, they would be able to sustain high standards of living as the scientists and the technical wizards would be able to figure out the ways to produce goods and means without any issues. As a matter of fact, the technology for searching alternatives to reduce overconsumption is no implementation of these alternatives owing to political reasons. However, these changes are perceived to bring reductions of existing problems only by some tolerable proportion. Von Weisacher and Lovins (1997) have proposed a factor 5 reduction, which is possible via “technical fix”. However, this factor is clearly undermined by the contemporary requirements. Lovins claims that it is possible to double world output while at the while at the same time, halving the available resource. By 2050, the global output would be 20 times more than today and there for it would be impossible to provide the needed reduction by Factor 40. The assumption of technical fix is focused primarily on the use of renewable sources of energy. This would also eliminate the issues like Green House Gases. However, with this also there is a contradiction and it is believed that the availability of renewable resources and the utilisation of the sources like biomass would not be enough for fulfilling the needs of the people by 2050 (Trainer, 2007). 5. The Quality of Life The paradox of “Quality of Life” clearly supports the view of Prosperity without Growth. Literature including the work of Eckersley (1997) and Speth (2001) suggests that the increase in the Gross Domestic Product of the rich countries does not seem to contribute to the quality of human life. On the contrary, the quality of life seems to decline in the richer countries. This paradox raises the question that for what reason are we striving for economic growth. 6. Challenges The economy has grown in a massive way and is now at the verge of depleting resources. Most of the economical structures today are driven by growth and hence, in absence of growth, they won’t be able to operate. Growth cannot be removed while leaving economy as it is. Fotopoulos (2007) points out at the fundamental issue of de-growth. Latouche (2007) raises the concerns relating to growth and socio-economic system’s structural relationship. If these undesirable impacts were to be remedied, then it would be requiring a widespread and radical action and we would be opting for an entirely different economic system. Daly (1991) calls for changes such as the phasing off of wasteful production, curbing CEO salaries and escalating environmental restoration. However, this requires a massive change in business activity and it cannot be achieved without extraordinary state regulation, compulsion and involvement. A change in climate of opinion and political situation is required for the same. 7. Transition to a Sustainable Economy As per Barack Obama (2008), “In the end, this economic agenda won’t just require new money. It will require a new spirit of cooperation… We will be called upon to take part in a shared sacrifice and shared prosperity”. Jackson (2009) further adds that the economic crisis presents a unique and valuable opportunity to invest in change. The short-term thinking on economy and prosperity needs to be eradicated. It has plagued our society for decades and it is time to replace it with a potent policy-making which is capable of addressing the massive challenges of tackling the climatic change and ensuring the delivery of lasting prosperity. The Fair Trade initiative is an apt example to achieve sustainable economy. According to Brussels -Commission of the European Communities (2009), the Commission has adopted a communication for better environment [3] on public procurement, and this complements the Green Procurement Guide of the Commission. The aim is to provide solution for public procurement, which is sustainable in nature. Many of the authorities have thereafter called for the inclusion of “fair trade” objectives in the procurement policies of their tenders. However, it is not yet extensive enough to safeguard the ethical and ecological standards in line with the supply chains. 8. Conclusion A change in the social logic is required. There is a requirement of strong trading standards for dismantling the culture of consumerism. There is also a significant requirement of enabling a stronger trading standard in order to protect the citizens both as consumers and as workers. As per Daly (2008), ‘steady-state economy’ is the greatest need of the hour. In his book “Prosperity without Growth”, Jackson (2009 aims to surface the modern definition of prosperity in accord with ecological limits. Many economists have constantly contributed to the same thought. According to MacKenzie, The Limits to Growth (2004) puts forward the computer modelling of the unchecked population and economic growth with finite and limited resource supplies. Revisiting the speculation of collapse, they show that ceasing growth is the only alternative of human subsistence and prosperity. With the boom of needs and ecological exploitation, the only thing that would be achieved is nothing else than the doom of entire humanity. Hence, prosperity without growth seems to be the only aegis that we have in present era. 9. References Brussels Commission of the European Communities, (2009). “Contributing to Sustainable Development: The role of Fair Trade and nongovernmental trade-related sustainability assurance schemes” Daly, H. (1989), For The Common Good , pp. 1-2, Boston: Beacon Daly (1991). Steady-State Economy, pp. 75, 100, 102, 103; Washington: Island Press Eckersley, R., (1997). Perspectives on Progress; Is Life Getting Better?, Canberra: CSIRO. Fotopoulos (2007). “Is de-growth compatible with a market economy?,” The International Journal of Inclusive Democracy, Vol. 3, No. 1 Hansen, J., et al., (2008). “Target atmospheric CO2; Where Should humanity aim?”, The Open Atmospheric Science Journal, 2, 217 – 231. Jackson, T. (2009). Prosperity without Growth: Economics for a Finite Planet, London: Sustainable Development Commission Latouche, S. (2007). “Degrowth; An electoral stake?,” The International Journal of Inclusive Democracy,” Vol. 3, No. 1. MacKenzie, D. ( 2012). "Boom and doom: Revisiting prophecies of collapse". New Scientist. Available at http://www.newscientist.com/article/mg21328462.100-boom-and-doom-revisiting-prophecies-of-collapse.html. [Accessed Jan 20, 2013] Meadows, Donella, Randers, J. Meadows, Dennis (2004). “Limits to Growth: The 30-year Update”, available at http://books.google.co.in/books/about/Limits_to_Growth.html?id=QRyQiINGW6oC, [Accessed Jan 19, 2013] Meinshausen, M, N. Meinschausen, W. Hare, S. C. B. Raper, K. Frieler, R. Knuitti, D. J. Frame, and M. R. Allen, (2009). “Greenhouse gas emission targets for limiting global warming to 2 degrees C”, Nature, 458, Page 1158 -1162. Obama, B (2008). From a speech on ‘shared prosperity’ that Obama made in Janesville, Wisconsin, 13February 2008, online at www.barackobama.com/2008/02/13/remarks_of_senator_barack_obam_50.php. [Accessed Jan 11, 2013] Trainer, T., (2010), ”De-growth is not enough’, International Journal of Inclusive Democracy” Von Weizacker, E. and A. B. Lovins, (1997), Factor Four : Doubling Wealth - Halving Resource Use World Wildlife Fund (2010), Living Planet Report, available at http://wwf.panda.org/about_our_earth/all_publications/living_planet_report/. [Accessed Jan 20, 2013] Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“ECONOMIC OF GROWTH AND DEVELOPMENT Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words”, n.d.)
ECONOMIC OF GROWTH AND DEVELOPMENT Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/macro-microeconomics/1466107-economic-of-growth-and-development
(ECONOMIC OF GROWTH AND DEVELOPMENT Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words)
ECONOMIC OF GROWTH AND DEVELOPMENT Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words. https://studentshare.org/macro-microeconomics/1466107-economic-of-growth-and-development.
“ECONOMIC OF GROWTH AND DEVELOPMENT Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/macro-microeconomics/1466107-economic-of-growth-and-development.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Prosperity Without Growth

Whats Wrong with Growth

The paper "What's Wrong with growth" discusses that the government has given enough powers to the sustainable development commission to take the necessary steps and recommend the govt.... This will lead to the growth of the economy and reverse the damage to the environment too.... But in the end, he says that decoupling is a myth and any amount of growth will lead to greenhouses gases and depletion of resources so one must be careful of the pace at which they are growing....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Poverty and pollution

However, if economic growth signifies progress, then logical environmental policies are necessary for lasting economic growth, or at least environmental protection and progress are compatible.... Environmental pollution can limit economic growth and the health impacts of pollution in a nation'...
5 Pages (1250 words) Case Study

Aviation Industry Sustainability

The paper "Aviation Industry Sustainability" highlights that the organization should address all issues in the quadrant if it hopes to remain for a long time in business.... It provides the managers and leaders of organizations with drivers that propel change and propose strategies.... ... ... ... Aviation stakeholders came together under the Carbon Management Group to respond to climate-related challenges....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

The Attempt to Improve Unilevers Business

The aim of this report is to analyze critically the attempts to improve the sustainability of Unilever's business, the hindrances to achieving a sustainable business.... The report will then recommend changes that Unilever can take up and be able to achieve business sustainability.... ... ... ... This essay analyzes that a sustainable business can be described as a business whose activities are environmentally friendly this, in turn, ensures that all its products, processes and manufacturing processes satisfactorily address the environmental concerns while at the same time maintaining a profit....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Needs of Future Generations Supporting Current Sustainable Development

without sustainable development, the current generation would benefit, but at the expense of tomorrow's generation.... The essay "Needs of Future Generations Supporting Current Sustainable Development" focuses on the critical, and multifaceted analysis of whether the needs of future generations are being met by current policies of sustainable development in the United Kingdom....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

The Battle of Ape and Crab by William Elliot

Analysis: Potentials for Prosperity Without Growth: Ecological sustainability, social inclusion and the quality of life in 38 countries.... prosperity is important in life.... The negative aspect of the prosperity is that the end upshot cannot be precisely known....
2 Pages (500 words) Literature review

The Human Population Explosion on a Finite Planet

The essay 'The Human Population Explosion on a Finite Planet' will try to analyze how the increasing human population can fit into the finite planet and is there any end of the growth of the human population.... The author states that various experts across the world have talked about that the finite world cannot sustain indefinite population growth with the help of definite resources.... According to Bryant, the exponential growth of the human population has already captured or degraded significant lands on the planet....
6 Pages (1500 words) Assignment

Key Environmental Problems of Sustainable Development

opulationThe growth in population leads to social issues, change in climatic conditions due to deforestation and urbanization, insufficiency of food, imbalances in the economy, developmental issues, and health issues (LEAD International, 2015).... As explained by the Brundtland Commission, sustainable development is satisfying the present generation needs without dissatisfying the need of the future generation (United Nations Economic Commission for Europe, 2005). ...
8 Pages (2000 words)
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us