StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The Exceptions of Law of Torts - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This essay "The Exceptions of Law of Torts" focuses on the law of torts that generally does not require one to be duty-bound to rescue another person. Various debates, however, have been conducted in relation to this but courts have refused to alter the judgment. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.8% of users find it useful
The Exceptions of Law of Torts
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Exceptions of Law of Torts"

Law of Torts: Exceptions Law of Torts: Exceptions The law of torts generally does not require one to be duty-bound to rescue another person. Various debates, however, have been conducted in relation to this but courts have refused to alter the judgment. This they mainly attribute to the value of individualism within the society that makes every person favor themselves especially in the face of danger and risk for survival. Another major reason is the unworkability of the rule requiring rescue due to the definition of terms it is mandated and when it is not.

The rising discomforts to this rule have led to various states giving exceptions to this rule thus stating the requirement by an individual to rescue another. This law they mainly bases on exceptional situations such as where the need for rescue arises due to negligence of the expected rescuer or defendant. This is both when the negligence is with intent or fault-free conduct. In the case of one party dependence or mutual dependence in life such as a ship captain and the seaman, such duty is said to apply.

Another exception is derived from a rescuer’s intent to rescue. Once a person intervenes and objects to rescue they are obligated to have a duty and must not leave the victim in a worse-off condition. It is also occasionally ascertained to be one’s duty to rescue where a contract stating the same is available. Though there are uncertainties as per the terms and forms of contracts of this nature (Scordato, 2008). In one case taken before the New Hampshire Supreme Court in 1898, the court judged in favor of the defendant.

This was after an eight-year-old boy who trespassed into the premises of the defendant placed his hand in the defendant’s machinery. In this situation, the defendant was not obligated by any duty to rescue the boy, and could actually further place charges against the boy for trespassing. This can be attributed to the fact that they had no relationship of such a dependable nature, the defendant had no hand in the boy getting there, and that rescuing him could maybe have resulted in him into bodily harm hence the individual nature to stay away.

Another interesting case of this nature is one regarding reporters and paparazzi and their duty to rescue others from danger. This is because many times photos are publicized of the dying moments of people in crime scenes and accidents posing the thought of whether the one who took the photo should have saved the person's life instead of taking the photo of their last breathing moments. This was brought into considerations and as current they do have the duty. As was applied in the case of investigation of the photographers at the fatal accident scene of Lady Diana.

They were being investigated for their failure to conduct their duty in saving the life of the people involved. It was however established that the cause of the accident had nothing to do with the paparazzi hence they had no duty to rescue them (Graves, 2002). Plus they could have feared getting closer enough to help so took photos from a comfortable distance. Again, in any case, the victims were pronounced dead on the spot hence could not have been saved under any circumstance. In the law or tort individuals have the duty not to cause harm to others.

This means that in their actions they should do everything possible and foreseeable to ensure that they do not amount to cause real harm to others. This may fall in situations such as victim and the doer are in a relationship such that the later cede their ability to protect themselves as such the former becoming responsible in duty to make reasonable efforts to protect them. However, just like in any other laws there are exceptions to this law that have been established in various states such as America.

These exceptions are there in the establishment that such conduct of activities causing harm to others was not intended or foreseeable by the doer. Such an exception was given in the case of Palsgraf v. Long Island Railways Company in 1928 (Smith, 2012). Here the defendant sued the railway's company because as they were standing on the platform of the railway's company, a railroad employee assisted a man carrying fireworks wrapped in newspapers to board a train. The package became dislodged, fell on the ground, and exploded throwing platform scales that hit the plaintiff.

The courts ruled in favor of the defendant through lack of establishment of a relationship between the two that would bind the defendant to be having a duty to protect the plaintiff and whether the plaintiff was actually in a zone of foreseeable danger. This brought into view that in such a case the plaintiff must be able to show that the responsibility to protect was the duty of the defendant and not in lieu of general duty on society (Scordato, 2008).

Read More
Tags
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“There is general duty under english tort law to rescue or assist Essay”, n.d.)
There is general duty under english tort law to rescue or assist Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1472329-there-is-general-duty-under-english-tort-law-to
(There Is General Duty under English Tort Law to Rescue or Assist Essay)
There Is General Duty under English Tort Law to Rescue or Assist Essay. https://studentshare.org/law/1472329-there-is-general-duty-under-english-tort-law-to.
“There Is General Duty under English Tort Law to Rescue or Assist Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1472329-there-is-general-duty-under-english-tort-law-to.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Exceptions of Law of Torts

The State's Tort claims Act in California

These procedures actually depend on the type of action that the aggrieved party is presenting before the court of law.... Introduction The California State torts Claims Act stipulates under sections 810-996.... that before a lawsuit for money damages is brought against a government entity, there must have been a written claim that must have been drafted and presented within the 6-month timeframe and there are usually no exceptions to this rule (Fowler & Fleming, 1968)....
3 Pages (750 words) Research Paper

Understanding Tort Law

The author of the paper examines Tort law which is a section of the law of England and Wales that deals with civil crimes.... Offenses and the intention of doing offense changes constantly and this have made the judiciary to respond by introducing torts to cover the different form of offenses.... The main area of concern has been crimes resulting from negligence and the resultant action has created torts that cover the action.... Unlike criminal wrongs, civil wrongs are of state interest and hence the police force has a duty to enforce the law by arresting the wrongdoers....
5 Pages (1250 words) Term Paper

The Legal Liability of Air Traffic Controllers

hile specific aircraft regulations can hold blameless the owners of aircraft, (see49 USC 44112 (formerly 49 USC 1404)), the law of torts still allows for the suit of companies on the basis of negligence.... 1.... In rare instances a wake encounter could cause inflight structural damage of catastrophic proportions....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Private Law and Public Law

However, the problem of ascertaining the applicable law in the case of torts is scarcely less perplexing than in the case of contract.... Specifically, the private law issue is whether DWI is liable for tort and contract under the law of Liberia (the country of the ship's flag), or the law of Nassau, Key West, and Grand Cayman (possible place where the tort was committed or the injury occurred) or the law of Florida where DWI's headquarter is located or the law the State of Delaware where DWI is incorporated....
4 Pages (1000 words) Case Study

Harmonious Family Relationships Between Parent and Child

The Restatement Second of torts defines intent to mean that 'the actor desires to cause consequences of his act, or that he believes that the consequences are substantially certain to result from it.... Restatement (Second) of torts, § 46.... Section 822, Restatement, torts (1939), reads: 'The actor is liable in an action for damages for a non-trespassory invasion of another's interest in the private use and enjoyment of land if, (a) the other has property rights and privileges in respect to the use or enjoyment interfered with....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Law of Torts: Private Nuisance

This essay "law of torts: Private Nuisance" discusses the case of Caparo v.... The law distinguishes that landholders, or those in lawful ownership of land, have the power to the undamaged state of the property and to sensible solace and ease in its occupancy.... Actually according to law jus tertii meaning the right of a third person, is not a good defense to sue in a private nuisance.... exceptions to the above rule may also be present as in the case of Hunter v Canary Wharf....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Webb Resolutions Limited vs E Surv Limited-Overvaluations

Surv Limited, the (defendant): was a case that presented before The Honorable Mr.... Justice Coulson in the year 2012.... As of the years 2006 and 2007, GMAC RFC was among one of the largest lenders with regard to mortgages in the UK.... ... ... ... Surv was one of the largest surveyors in the residential market (Underhill 455)....
5 Pages (1250 words) Assignment

Negligence in the Parlance of the Law of Tort

"Negligence in the Parlance of the law of Tort" paper analizes a case of negligence under the law of tort.... The law of tort is that branch of law that consists of various torts or wrongful acts whereby the wrongdoer violates some legal rights vested in another person.... Thus both Lynne and Susan and Paul and Susan are jointly liable for the torts and are eligible for paying the compensation for the damages although neither Paul nor Susan will be held liable for the mental shock that Mrs....
6 Pages (1500 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us