StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Gist and Theme of The Giver - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The essay "Gist and Theme of The Giver" focuses on the critical analysis of how the gist and theme of the book The Giver and its movie adaptation have been kept intact whilst adding various contrasts to both. The Giver is one of the most exhilarating reading experiences…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.6% of users find it useful
Gist and Theme of The Giver
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Gist and Theme of The Giver"

s The Giver is one of the most exhilarating reading experiences for middle aged children around the world. Written by Loius Lowry, The Giver offers an imaginative utopian world which cloaks many dystopian values as explained by the journey of a 12 years old Jonas. However, when the book was transformed into a movie adaptation, The Giver directed by Phillip Noyce managed to retain some of the aspects touched upon in the book while transforming other major aspects. Though the central theme and the story or the plot of both the movie and the book remain the same, there are significant differences in the technicalities involved. For instance, to add a love angle to the movie, the age of Jonas is elated to 18 years instead to 12 which transform the lens through which the society is viewed. Furthermore, there are significant contrasts in the ending of both the book and the novel, which accrued enough criticism. However, these are the apparent contrasts while many other inherent contrasts will be revealed in the paper. Therefore, the paper aims at exploring how the gist and theme of the books and its movie adaptation have been kept intact whilst adding various contrasts to both. The first contrast which changes the entire outlook of movie from what the movie had predicted is that the movie leaves out the essence of the Jonas character by readily jumping to the part where he is being prepared to receive the memory. In the book, there are chapters (around nine) dedicated to breathe in the look and feel of the utopian community where the rules and laws are explained over how deeply they impact Jonas. However, the movie simplifies this aspect by stating that rules and customs in the utopian community are somewhat strict. Therefore, the book tends to explicate the principles regarding classless society, government control, respect for elders, and conformity to values with more intensity. In instances where Jonas seems to deviate by the rules, the sense of shame can be sensed by the readers, an element missing in the movie. Furthermore, the movie also deviates from the essence of what comprises a perfect or an imperfect society, since the movie puts the entire burden of imperfection with respect to the sameness of the community on the elders. In other words, the movie merely leaves an impact where the audience tends to view the elders as the villains of the story i.e. the reasons behind the utopian community being flawed. However, in the book, one can feel the impact of belief systems and the inherent values where the joys and pains of the real world experienced by Jonas are exhilarating. In the movie, Jonas` decision to leave the community seems hasty and inspired by the attitude of elders, while in the book, one can relate to the insights and deep thoughts and beliefs experienced by Jonas. Furthermore, reading the book, the text-to-self mode is at play since Lowry had added such magnificent dialogues and quotes that one can`t help but relate oneself to the characters. For instance, how stuffed animals have acquired names in the books like an elephant is referred to as hippo, this small instance reveals volumes about the culture. Also, how in the book, Jonas has extraordinary eyes, and one can relate to such people in their lives. Similarly, the book has strong elements in context to text-to-world where the debate on democracy and principles of communism revolve in discussions more often than not; the book offers conclusions about how such a society would be like where everything would be same. We often study various government structures where essence of democracy and evils of capitalism have been critiqued. However, the book and also the movie to some extent reflect on how an equitable and a smooth society without competition for resources and ownership would be like. However, the movie may be analyzed with respect to text-to-text since the high tech drones and robotic elements may be related to other movies of similar nature. Moreover, elements like the significance of memory, significance of individuals and also how pain and pleasure both play an exceedingly important role in our lives is very well elaborated in the book. When Jonas received memory, one can feel how his outlook on life changes and how he inhales experiences of pain and pleasures, both of which he abhor as well as appreciates at a same time, creating a complexity all readers can relate to with reference to their own experiences in life. However, in the movie, the principle of sameness takes a different level where humans are so advanced that they can control their lives via dosages of injections. Coupled with appropriate colors and a love angle, the movie tends to take the story at a different emotive level where visual elements are strong enough to see how Jonas is struggling and challenging the way of live undertaken by the elders. Furthermore, the addition of music and age variables deviating from that of the book adds support to the movie which otherwise lacks the emotive value as strong as that reflected in the book. Most importantly, the ending of the book was ambiguous where space was left to predict future of Jonas while it is pretty clear in the movie where the details were laid out in detail and nothing had been left to the imagination of the viewers. Conclusively, the movie adaptation though reveals many contrasts, yet managed to keep the essence alive. However, if I were assigned the task of direction of the movie, I would have kept things simplified in terms of quality of life. That is, in the movie, the overwhelming addition of technology and gadgets de-humanize the story and the characters, which is why the effect of the book has been reversed. I would have used the technology to a bare minimum while focusing more on community building, customs, love, emotions, pains, belief system and other similar aspects. Yet, the movie The Giver in itself can`t be critiques in terms of quality since it qualifies aspect which the director had in mind. Works Cited: Lowry, L. (2014). The giver movie tie-in edition. Boston, Mass: Houghton Mifflin Harcourt. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“The giver Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/english/1672170-the-giver
(The Giver Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
https://studentshare.org/english/1672170-the-giver.
“The Giver Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/english/1672170-the-giver.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Gist and Theme of The Giver

Edward Jenner was the first ever to give inoculation to people/ invent the vaccine

Edward Jenner was the First ever to give Inoculation to People/ Invent the vaccine (Subject Name) Introduction The history of mankind has been ravaged by infectious diseases that claimed the innocent lives of many people.... ... ... ... Diseases such as small pox, typhoid, and polio are just among the few infectious diseases that condemned many people to death and left indelible marks of scars and disfigurations....
14 Pages (3500 words) Research Paper

Technology Gets Better over Time

4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

The Psychology of Gift Giving

This essay focuses on gift giving, perhaps because of the extravagance and importance of gift-giving rituals in both primitive and modern societies.... The freedom of the gift is seen as one of its main characteristics, while the idea that gifts are caught in a cycle.... ... ... ... I decided to help a group of children p by paying their school fees and foods so that they could achieve an education....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Liver Transplants for Alcoholic Patients: Should they be placed on the Waiting List for an Organ

Simply speaking, a liver transplant tends to be a surgical procedure that is carried on the patients suffering from liver ailments, so as to save their life.... Liver transplant involves the replacement of a diseased or malfunctioning liver with a healthy liver or a segment of the donated healthy liver....
9 Pages (2250 words) Thesis

The Benefits of Wearing a School Uniform in High School

The Benefits of Wearing a School Uniform in High School As far back as I can remember, public schools, which are paid for by the tax dollars of the American people, has never required their students to wear a school uniform.... Historically, American students have always worn everyday clothes to school....
9 Pages (2250 words) Research Paper

Persuasive speech

Organs have no use to anyone in the grave, so why not enhance the quality of someone else's life.... Organ donation is the most.... ... ... Your loved ones one day might be benefited from someone else's donation. ... ... t is time for you to become an organ donor.... Why?... According to organdonor....
5 Pages (1250 words) PowerPoint Presentation

Whats the best advice youve ever received or given

The thing about children is that they are innocent about most things in the world and require an older and more experienced person to give them a hand.... This was the.... ... ... Every holiday period, I used to go to stay at my grandparent's house.... It was a large house that had plenty of space to play in....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

The Investigation of an Environmental Disaster Involving a Mass Fish Kill Event on River Styx

"The Investigation of an Environmental Disaster Involving a Mass Fish Kill Event on River Styx" paper designs an experimental and sampling procedure that was to specifically identify the cause of the fish in river Styx and provides a long-term sampling program to prevent future occurrences.... ... ...
6 Pages (1500 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us