StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

How Reading one Composition Affects the Reading of Another - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The present essay under the title "How Reading one Composition Affects the Reading of Another" deals with the idea that when reading an essay about a certain topic, one is more or less being asked by the author to see things from the author’s perspective…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95% of users find it useful
How Reading one Composition Affects the Reading of Another
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "How Reading one Composition Affects the Reading of Another"

How Reading one Essay Affects the Reading of Another When reading an essay about a certain topic, one is more or less being asked by the to see things from the author’s perspective. When reading another essay on the topic, from a different perspective, one is inclined to still feel sympathetic to the essay written by the first author and read first. The topic of this paper, is how the reading of Liz Jones’ essay What I Think of the Fashion Industry can help us to better understand the somewhat veiled misogynism in an essay entitled The Natural Beauty Myth by Garance Franke-Ruta. Essentially, Jones argues vehemently on behalf of women and their health while Franke-Ruta not only disregards this aspect but mocks those who actively protest the manner in which women are treated and objectified through unattainable expectations, in the fashion industry. In Jone’s essay, she briefly explains that she herself worked in the fashion industry but had always felt strongly about ultra-thin women being the ideal portrayed. She found herself at a fashion show on one particular occasion amidst waif thin teenagers and quickly made the decision to discontinue her work as a fashion editor, “My decision to quit was partly precipitated by the failure of a campaign I started a year ago to encourage magazines, designers and advertisers to use models with more realistic, representative body images. Then I could not have anticipated the extraordinarily hostile reaction to my fairly innocuous suggestions from fellow editors and designers” (Jones, 2008). Jones had attended a summit on women’s issues and had the opportunity to hear from some of her magazine’s readers. These young readers of all shapes and sizes expressed how detrimental the ideals set forth in fashion magazines had adversely affected their lives. Jones is moved by the words of these young women as she so strongly feels that the fashion industry berates women, promotes unrealistic body types and essentially works against what women have been working toward for so long such as equality and the right to not be objectified. Reading Jone’s accounts from the fashion world as well as the opposition she faced by most of her collogues, when attempting a campaign to include more “normal” female body types as models instead of virtual skeletons as a norm, would incite anyone to feel compelled to rally alongside her. Following the reading of Jone’s piece with the article by Franke-Ruta entitled The Natural Body Myth, would possibly compel anyone not completely chauvinistic, to be repulsed by Franke-Ruta’s words, “Such a critique, which we hear over and over today, is based on a conceptual error. The beauty industry is not the problem; it is a part of the solution. American women today are the victims of a more insidious idea, an idea that underlies the American obsession with self-esteem: the tyrannical ideal of ‘natural beauty’ (Franke-Ruta, 2008). Obviously, Franke-Ruta admits that there is a flaw in the system, but attributes not of the problem itself to the fashion industry. Part of Franke-Ruta’s argument is based on the fact that American women are more obese today than they have ever been. This is attributed by Franke-Ruta to the message of “self esteem” that is widely taught and accepted. Indeed women should be encouraged to accept themselves for who they are but Franke-Ruta basically calls this a cop out or an excuse women may use to let themselves become overweight or obese, “over the past century, American women have changed their shape. Most noticeably, they have gained so much poundage that, today, more than half are overweight and a third are clinically obese. The sharpest spike in obesity has come since the late 1970s. There are all sorts of reasons, of course--from the rise of corn syrup as a sweetener to the increased portion sizes of our daily meals and our increasingly sedentary styles of life. And yet the doctrine of "natural beauty"--so favored by the self-esteem brigades of the 1970s and still confusing women today--asks women to accept themselves as this unnatural environment has made them”(Franke-Ruta, 2008). Fundamentally, having read Jones’ essay before reading Franke-Ruta’s, would probably not make too many people any more sympathetic to Jones over Franke-Ruta. Specifically, if read by anyone who has any compassion to the way women are treated and viewed. If anything, having read Franke-Ruta’s essay after reading Jones’ would only serve to illustrate Jones’ point that many if not most, in the fashion industry, are pushing unhealthy and shallow principles on women and their bodies. Ultimately, the solution to the strict criteria set by the fashion industry according to Jones is to change the ideals and criteria starting with designers and Hollywood, “Its time for the industry - the photographers, the editors, the casting directors, designers and the advertisers - to wake up and allow women to just be themselves. From the phone calls and letters I received at Marie Claire, I know that women are fed up with feeling needlessly bad about their wobbly bits”(Jones, 2008). On the flip side, Franke-Ruta’s summations are indicative of someone who although a woman herself, essentially defends the idealism that is so damaging to women, “Only in America do we think that beauty is a purely natural attribute rather than a type of artistry requiring effort. Look at the French: They are no more beautiful as a people than we Americans, but they understand that every woman can be attractive--if not beautiful--if she chooses to be. Yes, we are given forms by nature, but how we choose to present them is a matter of our own discretion”(Franke-Ruta, 2008). The type of statements made by Franke-Ruta are simple semantics defending the type of thinking that promotes eating-disorders. Women face severe scrutiny in today’s society based on their size and physical appearance. Many women have a tragically poor self image whether attractive or not. Women such as Jones have worked in the fashion industry and seen first hand, the terribly cruel attitude and judgment of women. She has taken a stand by advocating women’s rights to self acceptance. Unfortunately, Franke-Ruta has not only bought in to the idea of “no pain, no gain” but is pushing it harshly to her readers. The concept of health and caring for one’s self is important and should not be underestimated, but there is a difference between staying fit and healthy versus living on a Nazi concentration camp diet and a boot camp work our regimen. More likely than not, any individual who values women as important as well as takes women’s health issues seriously, would have an affinity for the essay by Jones more so than the essay by Franke-Ruta, no matter what size the reader is. Works Cited: Franke-Ruta, Garance,. The Natural Beauty Myth Jones, Liz, What I think About the Fashion World, Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“How Reading one Composition Affects the Reading of Another Essay”, n.d.)
How Reading one Composition Affects the Reading of Another Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/english/1546838-how-reading-one-essay-impacts-your-reading-of-another-essay-two-essay-s-are-indicates-in-order-descrition
(How Reading One Composition Affects the Reading of Another Essay)
How Reading One Composition Affects the Reading of Another Essay. https://studentshare.org/english/1546838-how-reading-one-essay-impacts-your-reading-of-another-essay-two-essay-s-are-indicates-in-order-descrition.
“How Reading One Composition Affects the Reading of Another Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/english/1546838-how-reading-one-essay-impacts-your-reading-of-another-essay-two-essay-s-are-indicates-in-order-descrition.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF How Reading one Composition Affects the Reading of Another

Care for Women and Disabilities: a Call for Citizenship

hellip; It also summarizes reading on Aboriginal women and home care and finally, “Just fed and watered”: women's experiences of the gutting of home care in Ontario.... Aboriginal women and home care This reading describes women with aboriginal origin as care givers and healers in their families and the community in general (Grant Karen 147).... According to this reading, everyone in a community has a role to perform and therefore, they should be incorporated in everything concerning home care....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Effect and Influence of Social Factor on Business

Out of all the factors from PEST analysis I am considering Social factor for discussion about how it affects business.... Identification of one PEST factor PEST analysis is an acronym for “political, economic, social and technological.... This essay talks about environmental analysis, more specifically PEST analysis, and shows its high significance to business....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Challenge of Leading a Diverse Workforce

Workers find it difficult to understand one another especially is they are from different countries of origin (Gordon & Whit, 2010 p.... Religious segregation is another challenge that ought not to be overlooked.... A large populace of employees has failed to accept the significant revolution of cultural composition at workplace.... Communication barriers among employees in an organization are one of the major challenges to diversity....
5 Pages (1250 words) Assignment

Business plan for a media product - The Reading Series

the reading Series is one of its kinds in the Arts industry providing opportunities to amateur as well as experienced writers to read their work and get them acquainted in the local circles.... Created by Kildare Nationalist columnist and arts editor Liam Geraghty along with Riverbank technical manager Paul Winters, the series was first commissioned by then Riverbank manager Denis Clifford in 2004 and it was commissioned again by previous Riverbank manager Marcella Bannon in 2005, in 2006 commissioned again by new manager John O'Brien and due to its success in the community, has been commissioned again for another series by existing Riverbank manager John O'Brien to run for three years....
18 Pages (4500 words) Essay

Exploring Alternative Avenues for Energy

The Sarbanes- Oxley Act is direct fallout of the Enron debacle and is mainly intended to protect investor interests and ensure that another Enron does not encore.... This is because innovations made by one company could be challenged by another, which may lead to unnecessary litigation.... hile industrialisation has its positive aspects of generating revenues, offering employment opportunities and raising standards of living of people; it also leads to depletion of scarce energy resources, seriously affects delicate environmental balances and leads to vital health issues - industrial wastes, pollution and lowered quality of air and water....
6 Pages (1500 words) Term Paper

Scientific Analysis of Measuring Energy Balance

As a result of this, it is possible to ascertain the gained and lost weight in the body. Two main factors affect energy… On the other hand, exercise from different activities as well as efficiency in storage of food metabolism and storage in adipose tissue affects energy consumed by an individual (Miles, According to Elia & Ritz, (2000), thermodynamic laws elucidate why energy can neither be created nor destroyed, but can be transformed from one state to another.... Its purpose was to analyse air volume as well as its composition to give a percentage of oxygen expired during the test and also the percentage of carbon (IV) oxide expired....
8 Pages (2000 words) Coursework

Improving Reading Comprehension Through Story Reading

From this paper, it is clear that the goal of stories is to stimulate one's thinking and imagination.... The goal of stories is to stimulate one's thinking and imagination.... one glance at the mind map will allow the viewer to decipher what the story is about.... The Meaning Maker activities test the readers' pick up of concepts and how they may relate.... he Meaning Maker activities test the readers' pick up of concepts and how they may relate it to previous experiences or to practical situations in real life....
20 Pages (5000 words) Essay

Causes and Effects of Climate Change

This research is being carried out to describe the layers and composition of the atmosphere, discuss reasons why the stratosphere is important and why the stratospheric ozone has been disappearing, and explain the greenhouse effect and how it is changing the earth's climate.... The greenhouses gases constitute less than one percent of the atmosphere....
4 Pages (1000 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us