StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Community and Citizenship - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The work of Joanne Finkelstein and Susan Goodwin, Community, offered two variations of the concept of community, the provincial and the modern. The former follows the traditional concept of communal living that is based on mutual aid and trust while the former is the consequence of urbanism and industrialization…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.3% of users find it useful
Community and Citizenship
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Community and Citizenship"

Topic community The work of Joanne Finkelstein and Susan Goodwin, Community, offered two variations of the concept of community, the provincial and the modern. The former follows the traditional concept of communal living that is based on mutual aid and trust while the former is the consequence of urbanism and industrialization. (p. 122) The latter is mainly about how the elements of capitalism and urban living have transformed the dynamics of the community from the solid communal relationship to a mere arena of exchanges that promote the interests of individuals. The traditional community becomes the more interesting of the two and we can see this as Robyn Ferrel narrated a rural Australian experience. In the narrative, there was the European attempt in establishing settlements and, consequently, in building new communities in an unchartered land. Such experience is characterized by several elements that are fundamental in several other discourses such as in understanding utopia, democracy and citizenship. From both of the pieces, Community and Pinjarra 1970, one finds that communities evolve. It does not follow, however, that when change occurs, the very concept of community is threatened to be eliminated. There is the lesson of history to remind us of the significance of the past and the traditions that holds society together. Topic 2: Communitarian Identity In reading Mark Reinhardt and Seyla Banhabib’s works, it is easy to understand how communitarian identity is seen as the ideological opposition to the liberal identity. “The communitarians criticize the epistemic standpoint of the Enlightenment on the grounds that this standpoint and liberal political philosophies… presuppose an inherent and impoverished concept of human self.” (Benhabib 1992, p. 71) The bottom line here is that the communitarian identity requires an individual to conform to arbitrary moral ideals and world views that are deemed necessary by a specific community as some price for membership. Reinhardt is particularly critical of the communitarian identity when it is considered as a political program arguing that “it lacks an understanding of cultural struggle.” (p. 96) I believe that communitarian identity – its expectation or requirement (explicit or implicit) is inevitable in today’s societies, particularly in liberal democracies with their moral and intellectual demands. It is up to individuals to filter out what are the good from bad ideals and views that define their communitarian identities. In addition, individuals must be able to maintain a reasonable distance from this identity not just to avoid the pitfalls of contributing in a collective mistake but because it is called for to balance its relationship with other identities such as the civic identity. Topic 3: Community and Citizenship Citizenship is fundamental in the existence of a community. Although this idea is interpreted and modified in various historical circumstances, citizenship is essentially the basis of the framework in which the state or, in this case, a community can expect and require a reciprocal relationship from its constituents. Carol Pateman’s work, The Fraternal Social Contract, discussed an interesting angle in citizenship, one that downplays the social contract’s role in a universal conception of citizenship because it is supposedly slanted towards the male. For Pateman, society and the community is essentially patriarchal, and that, “fraternity” becomes necessary in order for a civil individual to be integrated in a community. (p. 50) While Pateman’s commentary adopted an essentialist conception of men and women in terms of political theory, it helped outline the dynamics of community membership, including the rights bestowed on the members as well as how they are treated. The feminist approach to explaining community and citizenship received greater emphasis in Moira Gatens opus, Embodiment, Ethics and Difference. Here, feminity was used to underscore how citizen’s right should be addressed, particularly in consideration of their diversity. (p. 102) This issue is indeed important particularly in regard to rights and the community or the state’s expectation from its members. Conflict would be inevitable amid the differences in the way members think, not just culturally but politically as well. Topic 4: Strangers and Difference Sarah Ahmed (2000) argued that when people meet strangers, these are not entirely strange because a stranger is supposedly somebody the knowing self already knows, since the stranger is already constituted as strange in the relationship with the familiar. (p. 21) What is significant about this proposition is that it shows that others can be loved or hated or that it could be, in fact, easier to reduce differences. This is true today more than ever as geographical boundaries are eliminated by technology and global trade. At this point it would seem proper to distinguish difference from alienation. A glaringly important lesson learned from reading Ahmed is that difference or strangeness is not an entirely negative thing and in some cases it could even be desired. This finds support in Iris Young’s discourse on the public space and the cosmopolitan city: “In such public spaces the diversity of the city’s residents come together and dwell side by side, sometimes appreciating one another, entertaining one another… always to go off as strangers.” (p. 319) Indeed, there are downsides to how people perceive strangeness and difference. It is inevitable, for instance, for this to breed racism and tension within a community but in the increasingly globalized world, such incidence are becoming less because of the attention and criticism it immediately receives. Topic 5: Difference and Democracy Unarguably, differences or social diversity in democracy has both its negative and positive side. It is, for example, inevitable to fail in eliminating the incidence of antagonism, conflict and disagreements that comes with the pluralistic form of government. Another pitfall, wrote Chantal Mouffe, there is presently an increasing disaffection with the democratic institutions due to the cynicisms on democratic politics and politicians in regard to whether the interests of the people are being taken into account. (p. 80) Nonetheless, democracy is widely regarded as the best form of government because of this very fact: people with all their differences are accommodated and, as much as possible, are not marginalized and, in fact, thoroughly represented and are involved in governance and policy-making. In regard to the problem about pluralism, there are new ways being developed in order to address the challenge. For example, there is what political theorists call as deliberative model of democracy where the citizens are more involved in the decision or policy-making process. The model is founded on the idea that a collective decision culled from differing perspective is better than those of a single individual’s. (Benhabib 1996, p. 71) This model underscores how difference in democracy can be a strength when tapped in a systematic and methodical approach. Works Cited Ahmed, Sara Recognising Strangers, Strange Encounters: Embodied others in Post-Coloniality, London, Routledge, 2000. Ferrell, Robyn ‘Pinjarra1970: Shame and the Country Town’, Cultural Studies Review, Vol 9 No 1, May 2003. Benhabib, Seyla Toward a Deliberative Model of Democratic Legitimacy, Seyla Benhabib, (ed), Democracy and Difference: Contesting the Boundaries of the Political, Princeton, Princeton University Press, 1996. Benhabib, Seyla Autonomy, Modernity and Community: Communitarianism and Critical Social Theory in Dialogue, Situating the Self: Gender, Community and Postmodernism in Contemporary Ethics, Cambridge, Polity Press, 1992. Finkelstein, Joanne and Goodwin, Susan ‘Community’, The Sociological Bent: Inside Metro Culture, Southbank, Victoria, Thomson, 2005. Gatens, Moira Embodiment, ethics and difference, Imaginary Bodies: Ethics, Power and Corporeality, London, Routledge, 1996. Mouffe, Chantal For an Agonistic Model of Democracy, The Democratic Paradox, London, Verso, 2000. Pateman, Carole, The Fraternal Social Contract, The Disorder of Women: Democracy, Feminism and Political Theory, Stanford, Stanford University Press, 1989. Reinhardt, Mark The Song Remains the Same: Communitarianisms Cultural Politics, Jodi Dean, (ed), Cultural Studies and Political Theory, Ithaca, Cornell University Press, 2000. Young, Iris Marion The Ideal of Community and the Politics of Difference, Linda Nicholson (ed), Feminism/Postmodernism, New York, Routledge, 1990. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Community and Citizenship Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words”, n.d.)
Community and Citizenship Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/culture/1547963-community-and-citizenship
(Community and Citizenship Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
Community and Citizenship Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words. https://studentshare.org/culture/1547963-community-and-citizenship.
“Community and Citizenship Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/culture/1547963-community-and-citizenship.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Community and Citizenship

The Communitarian and Cosmopolitan Views of Citizenship

citizenship has been described as membership or sense of belonging to a society, community, a city or a town and has been expanded to include a country and the globe in general.... citizenship is that membership that grants an individual the right to participate in the political activities of that particular entity.... However the concept of citizenship implies that one has responsibilities and duties towards other members of the entity.... citizenship is different from nationality as nationality defined the legal status of belonging to a nation while citizenship on the other hand defined the political rights of an individual in a society....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

NationalityandCitizenshipinThailand

Both the regulation and widespread rights have been standardized under the sponsorships of the nation-state by means of citizenship.... The generators of the nation-states tried to typify the people so that it would be easier for them to be controlled through the standardization of citizenship.... This paper talks about the background notions and discourse that associates to nationality as well as citizenship with meticulous reference to Thailand....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Forum Discussion on Citizenship

The paper "Forum Discussion on citizenship" highlights that it is in our hands as citizens first of our nation and then of the world to be knowledgeable and understanding of what we and everybody can and should be doing with the common goal of goodness and harmony for the global community.... I will be evaluating the seven authors who contributed their opinion on an archived discussion forum focused on the issues of citizenship.... Dimmick has raised important issues on the concept of citizenship with rightful resources to support his message....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Media, Citizenship, Public Opinion and Spin

The person who have citizenship can be considered as citizen.... The person who have citizenship will have right to political participation.... World wide there are different definitions and laws regarding citizenship in various countries.... It is defined as a membership in a political community.... The community may be a city, town, village, state, nation or a province.... These citizens are the people, who are protected by the so called political community....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Equal Citizenship Rights in the UK

citizenship is defined as a socio-legal status bestowed with certain universal rights and duties on members of a specifically – usually national – community.... As a core aspect of this status, social citizenship is linked, with specific sets of social rights (which will vary… However, social citizenship is becoming evermore closely coupled to changing order of contribution and belonging as complex forms of social politics citizenship cannot be understood without an active theory of gender relations, and that political citizenship for women destabilizes private male oriented society and the family....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

The Citizenship Rights Of Asylum Seekers In Britain

The writer of the essay "The citizenship Rights Of Asylum Seekers In Britain" suggests that recent development in global politics, especially after 9/11 incident, forced Britain to tighten their screws with respect to immigration and granting citizenship to asylum seekers.... It is not easy for some nationalities to get citizenship in Britain even if they are refugees.... 9/11 has changed a lot of laws with respect to the citizenship of refugees in Britain....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Citizenship in Thailand: Who Belongs

This paper "citizenship in Thailand: Who Belongs" discusses the background notions and discourse that associates with nationality as well as a citizenship with meticulous reference to Thailand.... hellip; The studies of the alleged modern civilizations over and over again grab two key  point  of  views  out of which the former  stresses  on  an  incessantly incrementing restraining or authoritarian supremacy,  and the latter convention,  in views of  Laclau and  Mouffe,  appears  to  be  contradictory  to the former by  means  of  stressing on trends such  as democratic revolution or the expansion of citizenship....
7 Pages (1750 words) Case Study

Leadership Analysis

This should also be considered along with a full embodiment of Community and Citizenship ideas of the organization.... This paper highlights that leadership is always directed at striving towards achieving a common goal and leaders are required to ensure that the required level of performance is achieved from the followers in order to achieve that common goal....
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us