StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Philosophy of Death Comparing Dualism and Physicalism - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This discussion, Philosophy of Death Comparing Dualism and Physicalism, stresses that the assessment of death and its nature leads us into two perspectives. The first approach argues that a body of human being consist of a soul and the body, which agrees with the dualist view…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.3% of users find it useful
Philosophy of Death Comparing Dualism and Physicalism
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Philosophy of Death Comparing Dualism and Physicalism"

Philosophy of Death and Dying Comparing Dualism and Physicalism of the turning in of the assignment (PHI 220) Dualism and Physicalism The assessment of death and its nature leads us into two perspectives. The first approach argues that a body of human being consist of a soul and the body, which agrees with the dualist view (Barry, 2006; OConnor and Churchill, 2010). Therefore, dualist subscribe to the fact that the body dies and perishes while the soul survives death. The soul is believed to exist in some forms or fashions (Barry, 2006).

The other approach looks at death by assuming there is nothing like the soul. The concept subscribes to the physicalism, which argues that humans are physical in entirety (Edward, 1997; Barry, 2006). Therefore, when the death of the body takes place, the process does not provide any alternative means of sustaining our consciousness. Best arguments for dualism and physicalism Descartes and Plato championed the concepts of dualism. The first argument, which looks at the opposites states that the dead originated from the living and therefore the living, should also arise from those who died.

This argument states that the process of dead helps in liberating the soul. The second argument of dualism is based on the recollection; it states that the soul existed even before a person was born since there is power of recognising things, which are hard to learn (Barry, 2006; OConnor and Churchill, 2010). The first argument on physicalism ascribes that humans are physical in entirety. Therefore, when death of the physical body takes place, the process does not provide any alternative means of sustaining our consciousness.

The second perspective considers the soul as dependent on the body, meaning it cannot survive on its own. Contrary to the dualistic perspective, the soul and the body does not survive death (Barry, 2006; OConnor and Churchill, 2010). The stronger view and reasons I believe the physicalism argument holds more water because no one can provide evidence that the soul may not perish. Besides, the concept of separating the two (soul and body) raises questions and many concerns. Therefore, I think physicalism concepts raises genuine concerns on the argument by both Descartes and Plato, who generated many gaps in their argument.

The counter argument holds more water. Important of discussion on the study of death The death of a friend is painful for the relatives and family. Therefore studying it helps a person to prepare emotionally and spiritually. It also draws interesting discussions that opens the understanding on the death. References Barry, V. (2006). Philosophical Thinking about Death and dying, London: Wadsworth Publishing Edward, P. (1997). Immortal, New York: Prometheus Books OConnor T. & Churchill, J. R. (2010).

Nonreductive physicalism or emergent dualism? The argument from mental causation. In the waning of materialism: new essays (Eds Bealer G., Koons R.), pp. 261–279. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Philosophy of Death Comparing Dualism and Physicalism Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1700879-philosophy-of-death-comparing-dualism-and-physicalism
(Philosophy of Death Comparing Dualism and Physicalism Essay)
https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1700879-philosophy-of-death-comparing-dualism-and-physicalism.
“Philosophy of Death Comparing Dualism and Physicalism Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1700879-philosophy-of-death-comparing-dualism-and-physicalism.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Philosophy of Death Comparing Dualism and Physicalism

The Case Against Physicalism By Jacky Chang

This discussion talks that physicalism, the philosophy built upon the premise that life, as we know it, centers upon or supervenes on physical matter.... The Case Against PhysicalismBy Jacky ChangAbstract While there may be many strong arguments in favor of physicalism, it lacks much in fully expressing the human experience and journey.... Through the content of this document I will attempt to discuss some of the reasons why physicalism, in its reduction theory, does not adequately describe life as we know it....
2 Pages (500 words) Assignment

Ryle's Criticisms of Cartesian Dualism

The focus of the paper "Ryle's Criticisms of Cartesian dualism" is on Ryle's criticisms of cartesian dualism, an account of the mind offered by Ryle to replace cartesian dualism, weighing in on Ryle and Descartes: on which of the two accounts is more, immediate consciousness experience.... 15-16, Paragraph #2)The core of the objection is with regard to the Cartesian view of the dualism of mind and body as a category mistake and a myth of the philosopher, meaning that in essence those mental processes are miscategorized and made to fit a category to which they do not belong....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Nature Of The Mind

Descartes refers to the nature of mind by introducing a theory in support of substance dualism.... Descartes refers to the nature of mind by introducing a theory in support of substance dualism.... halmers theory of mind is known as property dualism.... From this relationship, there exists a kind of dualism between nonphysical and physical features.... On the other hand, property dualism is descriptive.... They are well thought out and provide a basis for comparing and contrasting....
2 Pages (500 words) Assignment

The Central Nervous System and Brain Without a Mind or Soul

hellip; Dualism is a philosophical argument that is in opposition to physicalism and is based on the belief that apart from the physical body, human beings have a nonphysical component of the mind, soul, or the self.... his positioning of the mind and the brain based on the assumptions made in physicalism means that damage to the brain translates to the same damage in the mind.... part from the assumption that the mind and brain are the same, another condition of physicalism is based on the belief that the physical world is causally closed....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Explain dualism, materialism, and Idealism. Which is preferable and why

dualism – this is the philosophy which states that for any particular domain, there are always two kinds or categories of things or fundamental principles.... Materialism – this philosophical theory regards material objects as the A PHILOSOPHICAL ESSAY (dualism, Materialism, and Idealism of (affiliation) Location of submission:Estimated word count: 306 (of text only)A PHILOSOPHICAL ESSAY1.... dualism – this is the philosophy which states that for any particular domain, there are always two kinds or categories of things or fundamental principles....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Hart -- Argument for Dualism and Sehon -- Substance Dualism and Simplicity

in this it is important to understand that substance dualism in philosophy asserts that matter and the mind are two Substance dualism and simpli Substance dualism and simpli focuses on a set of views that talk about the relationship between the mind and matter.... Substance dualism mainly focuses on the position in which the body and the mind are not identical, in dualism the view of the mind is that it is an immaterial… Substance dualism hold the mind as a substance that is not physical, hence the name ‘substance dualism....
2 Pages (500 words) Assignment

Different Views On The Physicalism And Features Of Them

The paper "Different Views On The physicalism And Features Of Them" discusses Lewis' and Jackson's arguments about physicalism.... The writer states that Jackson's argument is stronger since it is only one-sided, while that of Jackson addresses the two sides, physicalism and knowledge argument.... If this was the case with Mary, then the physicalism threats would not be there.... n the other hand, Mary lacked knowledge of physicalism, which is also against the knowledge argument....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Rejection of Grahams Anti-Realism about Mental Disorders

Graham argues that this is wrong because it is based on physicalism, which is a flawed concept with regard to its explanation of mental disorders.... Graham points out that the explanation by physicalism that the body and mind are similar because both of them consist of physical matter is wrong.... Graham's second argument is also about physicalism, he indicates that even in the unlikely case that it would be true, it would still make sense to view mental disorders as being both mental and real at the same time....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us