StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Materialism - An Objection to Analytical Behaviourism - Assignment Example

Cite this document
Summary
The theory of materialism states that any that has existence is material and that whatever is mental either has no existence or can be identified with material objects. This theory was first put forward by Thomas Hobbes who claimed that sense is what brings about materialism…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94% of users find it useful
Materialism - An Objection to Analytical Behaviourism
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Materialism - An Objection to Analytical Behaviourism"

Materialism - An Objection to Analytical Behaviorism The theory of materialism s that any that has existence is material and that whatever is mental either has no existence or can be identified with material objects. This theory was first put forward by Thomas Hobbes who claimed that sense is what brings about materialism. Through sense, human beings are able to think, dream, imagine, and even remember. For him all that is mental is either partly sense or stems from sense. For example if one feel pain, Hobbes claim that the pain is material since it is a motion in one’s body.

Therefore, whatever is mental is material to ones body (Cornman et al. 163). Kinds of materialism: Reductive materialism- Claim that material events within a person are the material entities. Eliminative materialism- Claims that mental entities are non-existent since they can be removed from human beings conception of the universe Arguments for eliminative materialism. 1. Analytical behaviorism, which analyses psychological expressions meaning within a language. 2. One does not need mental entities to explain certain purposes.

In other words, that there is no relationship whatsoever between mental entities and human behavior and hence there is no need to use them such explanations. Because of that, mental entities can therefore be eliminated. Analysis of analytical behaviorism. Analytical behaviorism contents that in as much as psychological terms may be used in sentences, there is no need for one to conclude that mental entities exist since those sentences can be changed and use terms that are only related to material events and items as well as states.

That not withstanding, analytical behaviorist hold that can still be materialists since acknowledge that something is true does no necessarily mean that you will commit yourself to it or that you will start following its tenets (Cornman et al. 164) . They ascertain that psychological sentences are just about forms of people’s behavior. The adopted analysis concept is the most important in analytical behaviorism. What can therefore of interest to us in our contextual understanding is the meaning analysis, a linguistic technique that checks meanings of linguistic expression in some two ways.

First, is coming up with a linguistic expression that is similar with the previous one and the second one is providing similar expressions but with additional linguistic expressions and also that which has expressions that are very different from the original expression. Types of meaning analysis 1. Explicit definition 2. Contextual definition Explicit definition does not apply to analytical behaviorism since they define things as they are. For example, a human is defined as a rational animal.

Contextual meaning is what is used in analytical behaviorism for it gives specific definition according to the context of the term. For example, contextual definition can be elaborated by using a sentence such as, in Kenya, 3.5 people die every day of H.I.V. and AIDS. If the assumption of the sentence is true, and some people can also be convinced that indeed it is true, and then wonder how a half a person can die since we said 3.5 people. Then we have to explain to them that they misinterpreted the statement.

Here we are not referring to actual people since there is no such a thing as a half a person. However, the expression in the sentence refers to ordinary people. Therefore, entities with contextual definitions have been eliminated and in ordinary entity expression has been left. It is this technique that analytical behaviorists use to create psychological sentences (Cornman et al. 165). Justification of analytical behaviorism Mental sentences can be made to be similar to those sentences that contain behavior terms and other term which are not mental and therefore, in order to describe behavior in a person, only mental terms will be used since the assumption is that mental terms are employed on all that is mental.

Ultimately, the justification become that mental entities do not exist (Cornman et al. 168). Objections to analytical behaviorism. 1. Belief sentences cannot be anaysed using analytical behaviorism. All efforts that were put in place to analyze belief sentences to behaviorism sentences did not yield anything. This was proven using examples which could not be changed to be similar with the belief sentences and if they were made synonymous, it was only possible because technical terms that did not have any use had been used (Cornman et al 170).

Since it is hard to turn psychological language into behavioral language, people use heavy scientific words instead of psychological terms. This does not aid the analytical behaviorist whatsoever (Cornman et al. 171). 2. The analogy between demons and pains. That when people caught diseases, the witchdoctors claimed that the diseases were caused by demons and the reason is that the witchdoctors had taken mushrooms, which brought about hallucinations but the reason why people feel pain worldwide is not explained and therefore eliminative materialism cannot be confirmed (Cornman et al. 173). 3.

Folk psychology and the human behavior. It does not give explanations and when it does, the explanation is not always good to explain why people behave the way they do. For example, sleep, and mental illness. This is contested by a neuroscientist who will give a more predictable explanation of why people behave the way they do. Hence, eliminative materialism is not proven otherwise (Cornman et al. 176). Work Cited Cornman, James W., Lehrer Keith, and Pappas George S. Philosophical Problems and Arguments: An Introduction.

Indianapolis: Hackett Pub Co Inc, 1991. Print

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Materialism - An Objection to Analytical Behaviourism Assignment”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1435398-materialism-an-objection-to-analytical
(Materialism - An Objection to Analytical Behaviourism Assignment)
https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1435398-materialism-an-objection-to-analytical.
“Materialism - An Objection to Analytical Behaviourism Assignment”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1435398-materialism-an-objection-to-analytical.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Materialism - An Objection to Analytical Behaviourism

Traditional Teaching

Remembering the correct answer is the priority, to which end, they are inundated with information, in which process, their analytical skills remain largely untapped and untrained.... Teaching is done in a linear fashion, according to a set timetable—i.... .... the lessons are gone through chapter by chapter, and without any deviation....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Managing a High-Performance Knowledge Sharing Network

In my personal journey seeking for knowledge, I do get to engage in certain habits of mind as I go through the four dimensions of knowledge management, namely: the analytical, information, social and learning dimensions.... The author of this essay under the title "Managing a High-Performance Knowledge Sharing Network" focuses on the idea of knowledge management....
15 Pages (3750 words) Essay

The Effectiveness of Incorporating Principles of Cognitivism

Making the timeline will challenge their analytical skills as they cut out Grandma Phoenix's trail.... Instructional Setting: regular classroom setting, students are grouped for the activities.... 25 students in class; eighty percent students are English Language Learners, predominately Hispanic, low income, at-risk students....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Expression of Mentality through Materiality of Object

When I wrote my masters thesis on reason and psycho-pathology at Seoul National University in 2009, collecting and researching materials to investigate causes for and symptoms of specific mental activities such as psychopathological symptoms or phobias, I came to be interested… Unlike the ordinary idea that differentiated mind from matter, this clearly proved that even things we had considered mental were kept under the control of matter (Harris, 2012:45)....
7 Pages (1750 words) Research Paper

The Development Theory of Human Resource

Kolbs Learning Style Inventory and MBTI (Myers Briggs Type Indicator) are two majorly used indicators, which help to assess learning styles acquired by individuals from various experiences.... Kolb's learning cycle includes four different phases, namely experiencing, reflecting,… Through the above four learning stages, individuals gather experiences that are reflected in their consequent acts. According to MBTI, different people have different personalities....
11 Pages (2750 words) Assignment

Main Aspects of Teaching Philosophy

This coursework describes the main aspects of teaching philosophy.... This paper analyzes the role of teacher and the school, motivation for students,  the personality of a teacher, educational environment, leadership, and organization.... hellip; This suggests, as a classroom professional, the teacher must learn to work within a system of leadership, apply socio-cultural lessons to dealing with student scenarios, and also balance creative learning with legal and leadership expectations as part of a performance management process....
7 Pages (1750 words) Coursework

Derbyshire Fire & Rescue Service: Management and Leadership

This paper "Derbyshire Fire & Rescue Service: Management and Leadership" discusses the activities within Derbyshire Fire & Rescue Service, an organization with multiple divisions and leadership responsibilities.... Like any other business, this organization has a well-developed human resources team....
8 Pages (2000 words) Case Study

Learning Numbers in Multiple Ways

Moss and Harvie (2015) mentioned that developing an analytical framework for inclusive pedagogy can facilitate the creation of an important tool that can be utilized to assess how teachers promote the principle of inclusive pedagogy in different contexts.... … The paper "Lesson Plan Example" is a great example of a report on education....
7 Pages (1750 words) Report
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us