StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The Dynamic Legislative Process - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Mr. Hamilton say that when the framework was set up more than 200 years ago, the central power of making the laws that govern the United States was give to the Congress. They started by understanding what American people's wanted, their hopes, needs, dreams and desire and translate them into public policy through the legislative process…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.5% of users find it useful
The Dynamic Legislative Process
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Dynamic Legislative Process"

The Dynamic Legislative Process Mr. Hamilton say that when the framework was set up more than 200 years ago, the central power of making the laws that govern the United States was give to the Congress. They started by understanding what American people's wanted, their hopes, needs, dreams and desire and translate them into public policy through the legislative process. He says that through the years, the process of legislative has really changed on how the proposed bills become laws. In the text book legislative process the quiz was tricky but I can say that the results did not as such surprise me because I got more than 50% of the questions.

In the public criticism section, I went through all the five questions asked and the response from political scientist and professionals and I can say that the exercise was quiet interactive and interesting. I indeed responded to the five questions based on my opinion and my rating was that I was generally comfortable with how the congress work as opposed to the previous people who responded to those questions who said that they were fairly dissatisfied with how the congress operates. In section 3, I learnt a lot about how the congress work not according to the way the public think things should be done.

For example in the opinion that the public thought that the congress was very slow in it process and Wilson responded this by saying things should not be that way because a public that is capable of doing good things quickly, it is also capable of doing bad things quickly. In the opinion of the public was that they dislike a congress that is always arguing and with conflict but Rosenthal opposed this and said it was very health when there is conflict in representative democracy as this helps to avoid concentration of power at any one place in the government.

He argues that if America was to be a representative democracy, then conflict must exist between decision makers. In general, the public like the congress to work quickly but it works deliberately slowly. They work like this to prevent bad things from passing in the heat of the moment. I agree with Hibbing and Theiss-Morse when they write that "Much of what the public dislikes about Congress is endemic to what a legislature is" because they lack an appreciation for the ugliness of democracy. Lee Hamilton explained the real legislative process by all bills before they are passed into law.

Let me say that I was surprised by the complexity of the whole process. The legislative process though complex is very health and necessary for any bill to pass through so that it when it is passed into law it workable among the people.Bill Frenzel who is currently a guest scholar at brooking Institutions in Washington DC is widely viewed as a leading expert in budget and trading policy, was a former member of congress for Minnesota for twenty years. He commented on deliberative process of the congress by saying that the system was made to run like that because before the congress pass any bill, they must consider a number of options.

He adds by saying that if the public that they have a problem with the congress there are courts of law with can intervene. He is happy the way the congress is run and he say it may not be run at a better a way than that. John Hibbing, a political scientist served an editor of the legislative studies quarterly and as a president of the America Political Science Association's Legislative Studies section. He commented about the deliberative process of the congress by saying that the structure was made to run the way it is to prevent bad things from being done and to ensure that good things are done.

He said that the system was not made to frustrate the public but to make legislative to be passed easily and if people wanted it to be changed, then they can change though they have to look in its effectiveness. He also said that the Americans view the legislator as that they just serve their own interest but that was not the case. I do favor a slow process that prevent things from happening because if good things happen quickly, then bad things will also happen quickly also.In the conclusion, Mr.

Hamilton says that the legislation process is complex and untidy and it allows everyone to contribute his views and it has allowed the Americans to solve their differences for over two hundred years. To my views, I can say the Congress really is an institution designed to meet the needs and wants of the American people. This is because, they deliberative legislative process has enabled them to solve their differences for over two hundred years. I have learnt a lot about the dynamic legislative process and I can see the reason as to why a bill take that long before it become a law.

ReferencesThe Centre on Congress at Indian University (2000-2004); The Dynamic Legislative Process, Available at, http://congress.indiana.edu, accessed on 7/16/2006 Jones, C. O. (1982): The United States Congress - People, Place and Policy, IL, Homewood Sinclair, B (1983); Legislative Studies Quarterly, Vol. 8, No. 1 (Feb., 1983), pp. 117-131

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“The Dynamic Legislative Process Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1524186-the-dynamic-legislative-process
(The Dynamic Legislative Process Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1524186-the-dynamic-legislative-process.
“The Dynamic Legislative Process Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1524186-the-dynamic-legislative-process.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Dynamic Legislative Process

What Lead To North Carolina Marriage Amendment Vote

An author came to the conclusion that subjecting the NCMA to a vote was a result of the legislative and socio-cultural developments.... In this case, the law on marriage was debated during the spring of 2011 legislative schedule in the state legislature.... The voting for Amendment One came about as a result of a legislative precedence that North Carolina had set previously.... One of the factors that led to the North Carolina Marriage Amendment (NCMA) vote was the fact that the law is dynamic and thus, subject to amendment....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Subsidiarity in the EU and Federalism

Anent thereto was the establishment of institutional reform increased the legislative power of the parliament with the introduction of co-decision processes (Eurofound, 2010a).... Under European context, subsidiarity refers to the regulation of power to ascertain whether in specific region where joint relative competence is evident and where the Union can decide either to take action or abandon the matter to member states....
17 Pages (4250 words) Thesis

Stronger legislatures bring stronger and more stable democracy

The explanation for its rarity revolves around the numerous dynamics it comprises.... A stable democracy is an embodiment of the “easier said than done” saying because it is simpler to envision and… Contrary to popular opinion, stable democracies go beyond regular elections, whether they are fair or not....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

The Westminster Model of Democracy and the Consensus Model of Democracy

According to him, consensus democracy is better suited to heterogeneous societies so that there is a certainty that minority rights would not be subject to a roughshod riding process by a roller-coaster majority in the legislature.... The paper 'The Westminster Model of Democracy and the Consensus Model of Democracy' presents the Westminster Model of democracy and the Consensus Model of Democracy which is being practiced in the modern world has engaged the attention of many critics and analysts....
9 Pages (2250 words) Term Paper

The Bureaucracy and Public Policymaking in the United States

Policymaking is not just about its outcome but most importantly the process by which it has been made, because the crux of public policymaking is the constant interaction among its key players: the institutions that draw the structures and rules which govern the making of decisions; the interest as represented by a group and individual stakeholders who would gain or lose in the policy; and ideas that would give logic to the policy (John, 1998, cited in Overseas Development Institute, 2007, p....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Guidelines and Rules of the Senate Committee

Members of the committees are appointed by a process set by the senate and also according to the varied rules of the parties.... hellip; The committee makes it possible for a legislator to attain specialized knowledge of the legislative agenda.... This led to the legislative Reorganization Act of 1946 that was intended to curtail this haphazard formation of committees.... A lack of a committee meant that most of the legislative business was done by a meeting of the whole senate which proved to be unproductive and inefficient....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Being Honest about the UK Presidency

After 1997, there were several changes implemented in the legislative process, however, the modernization committee steered clear of addressing issues involving the accountability in the executive.... In the paper “Being Honest about the UK Presidency” the author evaluates various forms of advancements, which have been embraced by different political societies in what some people view a positive step while to some it is a negative step because a lot has not been improved yet....
12 Pages (3000 words) Coursework

Assess the Positive and Negative Aspects of the US Political Framework

This paper assesses the positive and negative features of the US political framework established on the separation of powers.... nbsp;Separation of powers is an essential principle of modern political systems in democratic countries such as the US.... hellip; It refers to the separation of the executive, legislature and judiciary in that none of these three branches exercise total power....
9 Pages (2250 words) Term Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us