StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Operational Arts Napoleon versus Stonewall Jackson - Term Paper Example

Cite this document
Summary
The "Operational Arts Napoleon versus Stonewall Jackson" paper states that though Napoleon had contributed much to the art and science of war, especially the operational arts, he was not a man of words. His art of warfare became renowned due to his admiring interpreters Jomini and Clausewitz…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.6% of users find it useful
Operational Arts Napoleon versus Stonewall Jackson
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Operational Arts Napoleon versus Stonewall Jackson"

Operational Arts Napoleon Versus Stonewall Jackson TOPIC: What impact did Napoleon have on the art and science of war, and in particular on the notion of operational art? How does Napoleon compare and contrast to Stonewall Jackson? Table of Contents Operational Arts 1 Napoleon Versus Stonewall Jackson 1 Table of Contents 2 Introduction 3 Napoleon’s Influence on War Strategies 3 Operational Arts 4 Napoleonic Impact on Operational Arts 5 Stonewall Jackson 6 Napoleon versus Stonewall Jackson 6 Conclusion 7 Bibliography 9 Introduction In the words of Halleck, “War in its most extensive sense may be regarded both as a science and an art. It is a science so far as it investigates general principles and institutes an analysis of military operations; and an art when considered with reference to the practical rules for conducting campaigns, sieges, battles & c.”1 He goes on dividing it in four categories, including: Strategy. Napoleon’s Influence on War Strategies Until Napoleon, the act of war was there were either the state rulers or the trusted warriors who were regarded as responsible of the entire affair. However, Napoleon and Fredrick II had introduced a new concept of ‘warrior-king’ who can apply diplomatic as well as military power for his own aims “…and thus could more directly tailor military actions to strategic aims--and more thoroughly conclude peace following decisive military events”2. The warfare was in evolution even in the age of Napoleon. He had cleverly noticed the problems of sustenance and movement of armies in the battlefield and he took advantage of it. He had increased the mobility of the armies and had applied his creative tactics in the art of warfare, especially in the quick formation of army combinations. His creativity and insight into the affairs of War tactics had won him great victories. Critics believe that Napoleon’s victory lies mainly to his ability in synthesizing and exploiting the developments made by others. He did not rely on personal novelties; rather he tried to gain concepts from the war tactics applied by others. This approach ended the earlier “force employment, as opposed to weapons technology or logistical means”3. “Napoleon was about action; he did not share Jomini’s focus on principles”.4 To him, war was what is done in the battlefield, not in books. Though napoleon had not proposed a definite theory of War as his main concern was application of tactics, Jomini and Clausewitz have interpreted his actions and strategic aims to lay a basis for modern art and science of war. They had studied the operational circumstances and strategies applied by napoleon and they had added the active factors in the theory and art of war operations: pivotal points, main focus, climax, etc. Operational Arts “Operational arts” is a modern concept that deals with the conception and execution of military operations through the direction of military forces for particular strategic intentions. The whole operation involves the combining of the forces and allocating of the assets to planned units. Thus, it forms a bridge between strategy and tactics by building an association between the aims of war and the actual fight in it, and seeks to attain a level between these. Napoleonic Impact on Operational Arts Many critics believe that the origin of the concept of operational arts lie back to eighteenth century with the theorists belonging to “the Soviet inter-war”. However until recently, this term referred to only a combination of activities performed in the battlefield, such as: defining the routes of attack, scavenging and stocking, and barriers along with the growth of overall mans, unceasing processes athwart manifold battles of war, and the distribution of power among dogmatic and armed leaders. Later, Napoleonic wars as well as the industrial revolution developed them into a true set of operations. Napoleonic wars introduced large groups of inspired men-of-war while the other had provided with the sources for army’s sustenance. Some other critics believe that ‘Operational arts’ is fundamentally a modern concept and the earlier forms were mere developing stages. According to Kelley Justin, “It was only towards the end of the 19th century that a special meaning of operation--as a succession of tactical actions sharing a single unifying idea--was defined and began to pass generally into doctrine.”5 However, no one denies the impact that napoleon casts on the Operational arts. Bartholomees and other many has defined operational arts in a way to explain napoleon’s influence in it: “The essence of operational art lies in being able to produce the right combination of effects in time, space, and purpose relative to a [Center of Gravity] to neutralize, weaken, destroy (consistent with desired end state/[Commander’s] intent), or otherwise exploit it in a manner that best helps achieve military objectives and attain the military end state.”6 Stonewall Jackson Stonewall Jackson was American a Confederate general who had served America during the Civil War. His repute as a commander is quite well-known. It is said that Jackson had learned a lot from Napoleon’s war tactics. He is known to be a great admirer of Jomini and Clausewitz, and had internalized many a great tactics of Napoleon from their interpretations. Napoleon versus Stonewall Jackson As Jackson was a great admirer of Napoleon’s arts of war, he had adopted many of his war tactics and a great many of his war concepts, especially: swift mobility of forces, creative combinations of fighters as well as situational decisiveness of great import. Jackson is said to be in habit of planning flexibly at the start of the campaign like Napoleon, so that to modify it easily whenever needed. They both also had share the practices of precise preparations for the tasks keeping in mind the future prospects as well as analysis of the area location. They both had also shown a tendency to hover many objectives at the same time to create confusion and chaos among them. As far as the swiftness and speed of the actions in battlefield is concerned, Napoleon and Jackson both had realized the importance of this particular aspect and they both had commanded it from their soldiers. Another comparable quality demonstrated by these two commanders was the single-man handling of an operation. They did not rely upon their subordinates and remained secretive in their entire operations. However, this tendency had caused mush harm as it worked against the building of subordinates’ trust and sincere contributions. They also had refused to be influenced by contemporary dogmas and doctrine, and had interpreted the events and theories according to their own intentions and ideas. Other than these similarities, these two great commanders of past had observed many differences also. Jackson had not completely and truly followed the footsteps of Napoleon; he had modernized his art of war. His military tactic was based “on centralized command and control, rapid marches to achieve surprise, and rapid recombination of forces to achieve superior mass at the point of decision”.7 Critics relate his victory in Shenandoah Valley campaign (1862) as a remarkable success of his military intelligence and Individuality that had earned him far superior objectives than were intended. Unlike Napoleon, Jackson had never commanded huge troops in the battlefield. He also seemed to follow Robert Lee in his strategies of confederation and had not attempted to make any direct impact on the strategic level of war. Also, he had realized modern needs of defenses and had believed that to divide forces in U.S territory would be of great benefit. Thus, he had purposefully divided his troops at many occasions during his military career against the spirit of Napoleon. Conclusion Conclusively, we can say that though Napoleon had contributed much to the art and science of war, especially the operational arts, he was not a man of words. His art of warfare became renowned and appreciated due to his admiring interpreters Jomini and Clausewitz. Their interpretations of Napoleon’s tactics and strategies had won Napoleon even a greater number of admirers including the great American Confederate Stonewall Jackson. Jackson had adopted a great number of ideas from napoleon, especially the swiftness of military mobility, flexible planning of battlefield as well as secrecy of plans. But this does not mean that he proved to be a blind follower of Napoleon, he had devised his own tactics as well, particularly the intelligent division of troops according to US locality as well as avoidance of commanding huge troops in the battlefield. Bibliography Bartholomees, J. B., Harry R. Yarger, David Jablonsky, James F. Holcomb, and Frank L. Jones. "U. S. Army War College Guide to National Security Issues: Volume I: Theory of War and Strategy." Vol. 1. 4th ed. J. B. Bartholomees, USA: Strategic Studies Institute, 2010. Bartholomees, J B. "U.S. Army war college guide to national security policy and strategy." 2nd ed. J B. Bartholomees, USA: Strategic Studies Institute, 2006. Bismarck, Friedrich W., and North L. Beamish. On the uses and application of cavalry in war: from the text of Bismark, with practical examples selected from antient and modern history. London: T. & W. Boone, 1855. desaxx. Accessed May 18, 2011. http://desaxx.blogspot.com/2010/09/napoleon-stonewall-jackson-and.html. Halleck, Henry W. Elements of military art and science: or, Course of instruction in strategy, fortification, tactics of battles, &c., embracing the duties of staff, infantry, cavalry, artillery, and engineers. 3rd ed. London: D. Appleton & company, 1862. Kelly, Justin, and Mike Brennan. Alien: how operational art devoured strategy. USA: Strategic Studies Institute, 2009. Vego, Milan N. "Joint Operational Warfare Theory and Practice and V. 2, Historical Companion." Vol. 2. 2nd ed. Newport: Government Printing Office, 2009. Weigley, Russell F. The American way of war: a history of United States military strategy and policy: Wars of the United States. 2nd ed. Bloomington: Indiana University Press, 1977. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Operational Arts Napoleon versus Stonewall Jackson Term Paper - 1, n.d.)
Operational Arts Napoleon versus Stonewall Jackson Term Paper - 1. https://studentshare.org/military/1752741-napolean-and-stonewall-jackson
(Operational Arts Napoleon Versus Stonewall Jackson Term Paper - 1)
Operational Arts Napoleon Versus Stonewall Jackson Term Paper - 1. https://studentshare.org/military/1752741-napolean-and-stonewall-jackson.
“Operational Arts Napoleon Versus Stonewall Jackson Term Paper - 1”. https://studentshare.org/military/1752741-napolean-and-stonewall-jackson.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Operational Arts Napoleon versus Stonewall Jackson

Characterization in a Worm Path

stonewall jackson is a historical hero who was the Confederate cavalry's general during the time of the Civil War (Hopley).... nbsp;… The main character of the story, Phoenix jackson's characterization in the story is discovered fundamentally with the help of these themes.... As Phoenix jackson sets off on her journey through the woods to get her ailing grandson medicine, there is a long list of obstacles that she must overcome on her way....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Napoleons Methods of Domination

napoleon rises to power by taking part in the revolution and co-authoring the Commandments of Animalism.... napoleon's position as the rebellion's co-instigator confers upon him an unquestioned role of authority.... napoleon's private agenda is first indicated over the cows' milk.... claims napoleon, asserting his authority and responsibility, while allowing himself the opportunity to consume a luxury item.... Soon, all the milk, as well as the apples, follow napoleon's precedent, going directly to the pigs for their private consumption reinforcing the growing social gap between the pigs and the rest of the animals: the pigs do not work they supervise. napoleon's Methods of Domination napoleon rises to power by taking part in the revolution and co ing the Commandments of Animalism....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Diary of Napoleon Bonaparte's Descendant

The fact that I was a descendent of napoleon Bonaparte did not accentuate or deter our friendship in any way.... Today was the day I had been awaiting since the past few months.... The very excitement of seeing my friend, a friend who had been one without expectations or without even seeing me....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

The Passion by Jeanette Winterson

As the essay stresses greatly bothered by the needless loss of two thousand men when practicing in a storm at napoleon's insistence, Henri still describes him quite innocently as having a face “always pleading with us to prove him right” and how “his smile pushed away the madness of arms and legs that pushed in at my ears and mouth”.... This discussion explores that Henri loses his emotion for napoleon after eight years of following him and finding themselves still caught in the midst of war, watching men starve and freeze to death and villagers much like the people he left at home despising the French as he once despised the English....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Jackson asministratiom

The said act failed to successfully promote actions related to the said The jackson Administration The administration of Andrew jackson, the seventh President of the US is known for differentpolicies that he put into action.... For that matter, jackson established the rules needed to initiate the Indian removal.... jackson's successor, Van Buren though enforced the treaty resulting to 4,000 deaths from the Cherokees in the Trail of Tears....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

How Napoleon and his General Staff Took Centuries of Monolithic Parade Units

From 1799 up to 1815, napoleon has managed to expand his imperial guardsman; in fact, it became “one of the most famous military formation[s] in history” (Haythornthwaite and Hook 3).... During his regime, the general staff was formed and expanded to various parade units that… napoleon's name has been popular because of his loyal guards, and it took centuries for his men to remain the cream of French army.... This is because of his contingency From 1799 up to 1815, napoleon has managed to expand his imperial guardsman; in fact, it became “one of the most famous military formation[s] in history” (Haythornthwaite and Hook 3)....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

The Imperial Guards of Napoleon Bonaparte

This large group was later known to be napoleon's secret weapon – a tactical reserve for the battles he led.... It was divided into three divisions: the Old… Additionally, napoleon formed the Grand'Armee, also composed of special military men. The first division formed was the Old Guard – The Imperial Guards of napoleon Bonaparte The Imperial Guard was a group composed of elite French Army soldiers under the direct command of napoleon Bonaparte....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

The Case of Thomas Jackson

The current paper "The Case of Thomas jackson" tells about Thomas jackson who has died from a broken neck.... The brother of 18 year old Thomas jackson, who was found dead near his motorcycle, stated that “riding his bike fast really gave Thomas a buzz.... rdquo; The Constable proceeded to the spot on foot and that's when he found the body of Thomas jackson.... The brother of 18 year old Thomas jackson, who was found dead near his motorcycle, d that “riding his bike fast really gave Thomas a buzz....
2 Pages (500 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us