StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Pay for Performance why it doesn't work in the Workplace - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The article begins with an analysis to show the widespread payment for performance by managers and consultants involved in setting of payments for workers. This is tied to the belief that “organizations must give the greatest to who perform the best” and “the more closely…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97% of users find it useful
Pay for Performance why it doesnt work in the Workplace
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Pay for Performance why it doesn't work in the Workplace"

Pay for Performance why it does not work in the Workplace The article begins with an analysis to show the widespread payment for performance by managers and consultants involved in setting of payments for workers. This is tied to the belief that “organizations must give the greatest to who perform the best” and “the more closely performance, the more powerful its motivation effect” (p 120). The other believes that the basis for this motivation is behaviorism, which is pervasive and has axiomatic precepts.

The other basis for a reward system is Theory X by Douglas McGregor stating that people do not like working and has to be controlled and coerced to get anything done. To show the extensive use of the reward system, the author writes on using rewards to recognize teamwork, monetary rewards for employees for undertaking trainings and gaining new skills. The author states that rewards often impede than they enhance performance on many tasks with specific emphasis to those that require creativity with the example of Japan and Germany countries that do not use reward incentives and are successful in employee motivation.

The other further explores the fact that there are no empirical studies linking motivation to rewards showing poor implementation of compensation systems. In fact, research by Jenkins in 1986 shows no relation between quality performance and rewards (p 124). In a case where incentives were withdrawn, production decreased then after sometime rose to reach a better level than when there were incentives further showing that incentives do not motivate workers for quality or higher productivity (p 124).

The author then delves into the reasons for the failure of incentives including lack of necessity that is the introduction of incentives unnecessarily resulting in lack of any impact on performance. The second reason is secrecy where there is no transparency on each employees earning leading to overestimation and belief of differences in pay resulting in low morale and turmoil at the workplace. Other reasons are lack of match between performances and pay and expense in rewards solved via using noncash rewards.

The other reason is too big versus too small incentives where small incentives do not have an impact while large ones are not received by all the workers resulting in failure of incentives to motivate performance. Short-term versus long-term incentives are the other reasons for incentives failure where employees may make decisions countering long-term interests when incentives base on short-term performance. Objectivity versus subjectivity, performance evaluation being a futility, and that pay is not a motivator since money is not the only motivator in life is the other reasons for failure of the incentive system.

The author analyzes the different reasons that have showed the need for better working conditions and other factors other than monetary rewards for better performance, but also states the need for adequate and fair compensation. He believes assuming “money is what drives people is adopting n impoverished understanding of human motivation” (p 134). The author then articulates the problems of rewards at the work after explaining the nine reasons for failure of incentives to motivate employee productivity.

That rewards punish employees whose performance are below a set level is the first problem of rewards and is unpleasant, disrespectful, and offensive resulting in failure of incentives to spur productivity. The other problem of rewards is that it ruins relationships, as employees will fail to cooperate aiming to gain the rewards for individual performance reducing the overall productivity. Creativity declines with rewards due to the reduction in risk taking for employees take ion tasks they are asked to do only to attain the rewards.

Willingness to do other things to spur quality is reduced by rewards at the workplace. The last reason for failure of reward system and the problem of rewards is that rewards undermine interest in the job and its performance. The other also points to the fact that “incentive plans do not respond to the extrinsic orientation exhibited by some workers so much as they create this focus on financial factors” (p 141). The article concludes with the assertion that Behaviorism has had a major impact on work through incentive plans and other programs but has not been effective in delivering the desired results.

This is evidenced by the failure of the incentive system to spur quality performance at the workplace.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Pay for Performance why it doesn't work in the Workplace Essay”, n.d.)
Pay for Performance why it doesn't work in the Workplace Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/management/1664758-pay-for-performance-why-it-doesnt-work-in-the-workplace
(Pay for Performance Why It doesn'T Work in the Workplace Essay)
Pay for Performance Why It doesn'T Work in the Workplace Essay. https://studentshare.org/management/1664758-pay-for-performance-why-it-doesnt-work-in-the-workplace.
“Pay for Performance Why It doesn'T Work in the Workplace Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/management/1664758-pay-for-performance-why-it-doesnt-work-in-the-workplace.
  • Cited: 1 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Pay for Performance why it doesn't work in the Workplace

The Effects and Outcomes of Stress It Has on the Individuals and on Organisation

General Stress Stress is defined as the way in how an employee feels when they have to respond to a change in demand in the workplace.... There can be a number of situations for stress to occur in the workplace.... It also has a negative impact on the workplace profits and productivity of the organization.... There are a number of categories of Job Stressors which the employees feel at the workplace.... The physical environment of the workplace also plays an important role (NHS, 2013)....
8 Pages (2000 words) Term Paper

International Trade & Business

A project-based organization just doesn't work in India.... In India they replicate this successful motivation and reward system - and it doesn't work.... Very often we experience, that senior management who is responsible for the global operation is focused on financial performance and making sure that everybody (employees) globally apply to the same rules within the same organizational setup.... The only problem is that it suppresses the national cultures of the employees, which unfortunately leads to cultural friction, which inevitable leads to poorer corporate performance due to demotivated employees and inefficiency....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Being a Leader and Leadership Styles

However, it doesn't materialize completely until all the concerned people within its scope are prepared and ready most especially for its unexpected consequences.... In a leader - follower situation, both are essential in the realization of goals and objectives.... Leadership is necessary to build effective teams, and how each responds to every circumstance is significant....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Importance of Training in Public Safety

This is why it is essential to discuss the issue in more details.... In order to see the importance of the public safety training in public personnel management, the examples of workplace violence will be taken; they often become the causes of deaths and are neglected in the same way, thus needing special attention.... hellip; The main conclusion of the work is that HRM play essential role in developing policies for safety training implementation in the public entities and private companies....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

Performance Appraisal Strategies

The authors of the book Creating workplace Community: Motivation Solutions, Ideas, and Philosophies for Motivating Ourselves and Other, note, that Performance is considered to be a function of ability and motivation.... The annual feedback on the work of each of the employees is required from the manager, to define, whether the current position of the worker is right for him.... Performance appraisal defines whether the workers perform his tasks fully, whether he is suitable for the type of work he is doing, it evaluates the quality of his work....
3 Pages (750 words) Assignment

Impact of Attitude in the Workplace

This paper "Impact of Attitude in the workplace" discusses the way the employee have their attitudes at the workplace that affects the success of the organization.... The productivity level of the organization is affected by the behavior of the attitudes in the workplace.... A healthy and positive attitude in the workplace is extremely important for the organization to run successfully in the business market.... Their designation in the workplace also affects their behavior at work....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Corporate Crimes: Work Related Harm

When it comes to work-related harm, some workers find a way of explaining their injuries whereas some may be concerned about their work future in the event of seeking redress.... The paper focuses on corporate crimes which do not only include in its definition the crimes of tax evasion and the embezzlement of funds....
8 Pages (2000 words) Term Paper

Work and Organizational Psychology

Such kind of competition makes employees compete, which raises their personal results, however, it doesn't lead to hostile competitiveness which ruins professional relationships and increases the possibility of workers' failures.... From the paper "work and Organizational Psychology" it is clear that such thing as a vocation in fact depends not only on a person's natural talents and abilities, but also it depends on the skills that a person learns throughout the entire lifespan....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us