StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Theories of Justice and Equality by Michael Walzer - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper “Theories of Justice and Equality by Michael Walzer” evaluates Walzer’s concept as follows: “In formal terms, complex equality means that no citizen’s standing in one sphere or with regard to one social good can be undercut by his standing in some other sphere, with regard to some other good"…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.1% of users find it useful
Theories of Justice and Equality by Michael Walzer
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Theories of Justice and Equality by Michael Walzer"

The absence of X's advantage over Y is called a "blocked exchange" which in practice maintains boundaries between social institutions and practices. Inequities in one area are acceptable but cumulative and overlapping inequalities are not permissible. An accumulation of these inequalities can be the result of two different processes: The influential position within one sphere can be used to gain access to a similar position in a different sphere. The notion of complex equality is aimed mainly at eradicating the possibility of this kind of exchange.

Power positions within two (or more) different spheres originate from a single common cause. This would imply that Citizen X has one single characteristic, which makes him excel both in works of literature, as in politics and in economic entrepreneurship. The theory of complex equality does not explicitly address this as a possible cause of cumulative inequalities (Hooghe, 1999, p.211). In summary, Walzer's complex of equality i. The notion of "overall equality" should not be taken literally for; a.) a higher ranking official cannot be offset against a lower ranking in another sphere and b.) in reality, it will be possible to find individuals who consistently outrank others across important spheres so that they are overall better off than the others.

Theoretically, if spheres are independent of each other (and the variables that determine rankings in different spheres do not co-vary), it is mathematically or statistically plausible that inequalities would cancel each other out if these can be reduced to a common denominator or metric. In contrast, under simple equality, the variables determining rankings in different spheres will more often than not correlate significantly, so that even, theoretically, overall equality will not prevail. It should also be noted that Walzer does not rule out the possibility of a particular individual becoming dominant in all spheres and thus, that overall inequality will triumph over complex equality but he believes that as long as the boundaries between spheres are policed efficiently, this is highly unlikely (Van Wyk, 2005, p292). Prof. Walzer thinks that domination is not derived from dominant human beings but it is mediated by a set of social goods.

He claims that "we have to understand and control social goods; we do not have to stretch or shrink human beings" (Walzer, 1983, xiii). So, instead of reducing distributive justice to some simple principle of egalitarian form, Walzer openly acknowledges the plurality of principles of justice and seeks to make this very pluralism the basis of equality (Miller & Walzer, 1995).

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Theories of Justice and Equality by Michael Walzer Essay, n.d.)
Theories of Justice and Equality by Michael Walzer Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1500354-theories-of-justice-and-equality-by-michael-walzer
(Theories of Justice and Equality by Michael Walzer Essay)
Theories of Justice and Equality by Michael Walzer Essay. https://studentshare.org/law/1500354-theories-of-justice-and-equality-by-michael-walzer.
“Theories of Justice and Equality by Michael Walzer Essay”. https://studentshare.org/law/1500354-theories-of-justice-and-equality-by-michael-walzer.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Theories of Justice and Equality by Michael Walzer

National Healthcare Insurance

Walzer's major concern on progression to complex equality emphasizes on dominance in a particular sphere of justice and not (principally) on the basis of the monopoly in that given sphere.... michael walzer's theory of distributive justice presents a pluralistic and particularistic approach to equality.... He argues that the principles of a society should follow the historical and cultural setting of that society, that is, universal principles of justice does not exist, that distribution of different social goods should follow different principles, and that these different principles display different meanings of social goods that are products of cultural and historical particularistic approach....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Ethics and Public Administration

Whereas, people cringe at the legitimating mendacity though by government people s, people have the true walzer's admonition that “no government people can survive in politics without getting their hands dirty.... The discussion will analyze the official deception defense as outlined by Machiavelli and walzer, ethical theories that guide political behavior and code of conduct and finally outline why government people are justified to get their hands dirty.... Therefore, to ensure effectiveness and transparency in their public work, government people subscribe to various ethics theories....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Answering the question

michael walzer tries to develop just such a moral case: summarize one of his arguments in favor of immigration restriction.... michael walzer is a defender of immigration restriction.... Walzer believes that membership is a fundamental component of his theory of justice.... The theory of justice does not focus on universal principles but instead concerned on the specificity of history, customs and membership.... On the other hand, Caren objects Walzer's arguments on the necessity of restricting immigration based on the theory of justice....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Liberalism in International Political Economy Compared with Marxism and Realism

Also, there will be no inequality because everyone is experiencing similar circumstances, and unless there are problems in the ruling body itself, under Marxism there will be peace, equality, emancipation, and justice because people share the same ideas and beliefs like in Liberalism.... Liberalism and Marxism may share some similarities such as the importance of equality, but these two theories differ in other aspects.... However, this is contested by Marxism ideas, saying that while everyone may acquire benefit from participating in trade and commerce, the equality of gains will not be absolute among all parties....
13 Pages (3250 words) Research Paper

Amartya Sen and Global Justice

Sen is one of the foremost theorists on the subject of justice and human rights; his works have been widely read and critiqued not only by his peers but by concerned civilians in all parts of the world.... In his books Development as Freedom, Capability and Wellbeing, and equality of What Sen has focused his intellectual energies on designing theoretical models from which he imagines people on the whole would benefit in terms of gaining access to their basic human rights like clean water, food, shelter and racial and sexual equality....
19 Pages (4750 words) Book Report/Review

Theory of Complex Equality

The author of the present case study "Theory of Complex Equality" states that michael walzer (13 March 1935) is a political theorist and philosopher of society, politics, and ethics currently working as a professor at the Institute for Advanced Study in Princeton, New Jersey.... hellip; michael walzer has written on a wide range of topics, including just and unjust wars, nationalism, ethnicity, economic justice, criticism, radicalism, tolerance, and political obligation....
11 Pages (2750 words) Case Study

No War in the Modern World Can Possibly Be Just

Such theories have proven to be incoherent, and walzer's just war theory is a case in point.... nbsp;… Many arguments and theories have been developed by proponents of contemporary war in an attempt to decriminalize war.... From the paper "No War in the Modern World Can Possibly Be Just," it is evident that it is a tall order to wage a just war in modern times....
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay

Illegal Drugs Becoming Legal in the US

To support the argument in favor of legalization, authors pull in the theories of John Stuart Mill, who espoused that adult citizens should have the right to make their own choices regarding whether or not to participate in harmful activity as long as it does no harm to others, a theory that has been largely ignored in the decisions regarding alcohol and tobacco, but not the Class C substances such as marijuana....
6 Pages (1500 words) Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us