StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Legal Considerations The Terri Schiavo's Case - Research Paper Example

Cite this document
Summary
Legal Consideration; Terri Schivo’s Case Author Institution Legal Consideration; Terri Schivo’s Case Judicial Process Article III of the United States constitution guarantees a fair trial for every person who commits the crime before the jury and competent judgement…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.1% of users find it useful
Legal Considerations The Terri Schiavos Case
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Legal Considerations The Terri Schiavo's Case"

Legal Consideration; Terri Schivo’s Case Legal Consideration; Terri Schivo’s Case Judicial Process Article III of the United States constitution guarantees a fair trial for every person who commits the crime before the jury and competent judgement. Fourth, fifth and sixth constitution amendments provide additional protections for people accused of crime such as the right to prevent self-incrimination and legal representation. The criminal proceedings may be conducted through federal law based on the extent and nature of the crime (William, 2003).

Typically, a judicial process begins with arrest by law enforcement officer. When the jury decides to deliver indictment, the accused appears before the judge, formally charged with the crime, during which he/she enters a plea. Then, the defendant reviews the evidence that the case presents in order to come up with a legal argument. The case then undergoes trial under decision of the jury. Dismissal of the charges takes place when the defendant proves not guilty; otherwise, the judge gives the sentence that can be fine, execution or prison time.

After the trial, a case may be appealed in the appellate court, which takes its decisions, based on record of cases established by the trial court (William, 2003). The court of appeal has the final decision. The litigant losing in court of appeal may file the petition with the Supreme Court for a review. Healthcare Law Healthcare law offers choices to consumers and provides ways through which the insurance companies are accountable. The major features of the law include rights and protections, insurance choices, insurance costs, and laws on employers.

For instance, the preventive care offers protection for the family health where they assist in preventing illnesses and improve their health without additional costs. Basically, each of the key feature is sub-divided into sections such as, the insurance cost covers the young annual and lifetime limits, the rate review and the changes of flexible spending account among others (Felos, 2005). Professional Standards of Practice The professional standards of the practice act as guidelines when issuing professional judgment towards determination of appropriate actions to take in certain situations.

The standards are not regulations or laws. This is because the practices in a certain profession relates to different responsibilities. The organizations develop standards of practice using a panel of legal handbook and inputs from leaders of the profession. Taking the case of Terri Schiavo’s story, Terri’s parents fought against the removal of the feeding tube. After failure in trial courts, they appealed to the three branches of government at federal and state levels. This failed when the Greer, circuit court judge ordered the removal of the feeding tube based on Florida law.

This happened after Michael;Terri’s husband said that Terri disliked the idea of living in permanent vegetative state. However, Terri died thirteen days after removal of feeding tube (Greer, 2003). Cases like Cruzan and Quilan remain active after Terri’s controversy. This has led to the establishment of laws to deal with incompetent individuals who withdraw the life-sustaining treatment and artificial nutrition. Malpractice and Disciplinary Action Issues Michael filed a malpractice suit in 1992 against Terri’s obstetrician arguing of his failure to diagnose bulimia as a major cause of her infertility.

The doctor failed to take Terri’s medical history after she stopped menstruating, and Michael believed that this could have revealed the eating disorder. A friend to Terri testified during the case that she knew her to be bulimic. Michael won the case in November 1992. After payment of Terri’s medical expenses, the parents to Terri demanded to have a share of malpractice money. This led to the end of their friendship. Cause of the fall out is quite debatable (Felos, 2005). Ethical issues Though irrelevant to ethical and legal issues, animosity between Michael and Terri’s parents became a public matter.

This aroused views from different people who believed that they were all motivated by their own interest but not that of their daughter/wife. The parents believed that Michael cared more of money than Terri’s life. However, trial court found no basis for the charges by Terri’s parents. Terri’s parents made efforts to remove Michael, as Terri’s guardian arguing that he cared little for Terri, and worse still because he was living with another woman and had two children with her. The court concluded that Michael completely attended Terri.

He sought approval of the court to remove the feeding tube in 1998 (Felos, 2005). Withdrawal of artificial nutrition for persons in permanent vegetative state was permitted so long as the withdrawal is upon the interests of the parents. Michael was, however, the proxy since Terri had not designated anyone, and had to make decisions for her (William, 2003). However, Michael knew that Terri’s parents were against the decision, and he instead asked the local probate court for removal of the feeding tube.

This saw the death of Terri. References Felos, G. (2005). Respondent Michael Schiavo's opposition to application for injunction, Case No.: 04A-825. USA: Blue Dolphin Publishing. Greer, G. (2003). Circuit Judge. In re: The guardianship of Theresa Marie Schiavo, Incapacitated. Michael Schiavo, as Guardian of the person of Theresa Marie Schiavo, Petitioner, v. Robert Schindler and Mary Schindler, Respondents. Florida: Judicial Circuit. William, R. L. (2003). Schiavo's wishes recalled in records. St. Petersburg Times Online.

Retrieved 2006-01-05.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Legal Considerations The Terri Schiavo's Case Research Paper”, n.d.)
Legal Considerations The Terri Schiavo's Case Research Paper. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1480071-legal-considerations-the-terri-schiavo-s-case
(Legal Considerations The Terri Schiavo'S Case Research Paper)
Legal Considerations The Terri Schiavo'S Case Research Paper. https://studentshare.org/law/1480071-legal-considerations-the-terri-schiavo-s-case.
“Legal Considerations The Terri Schiavo'S Case Research Paper”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1480071-legal-considerations-the-terri-schiavo-s-case.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Legal Considerations The Terri Schiavo's Case

Legal Case in Business

The study "Legal case in Business" presents an analysis of a business legal case on the issues of a valid contract.... Further, she accused Morris of knowing that the competitor was about to open up and therefore she was commencing legal action to rescind the contract based on fraudulent misrepresentation....
9 Pages (2250 words) Case Study

Contract Legal Case

The study "Contract Legal case" discusses managing a contract legal case between two persons, an owner of the hotel and a worker.... As explained by Marsh and Soulsby (1987), for the court to intervene and make any person liable for damages in case one of the parties breaks the agreement, the said agreement must have the following important features: parties must have the intention to create legal relations; there must be a firm agreement between the parties showing the unconditional acceptance of an offer; a consideration wherein each of the parties provides or promises to provide something in exchange for what the other is to provide; for certain types of agreement, it must be in a specified form to be valid; it must be indefinite terms for the courts to determine what the parties have decided upon; and finally, it must be legal and not contrary to public policy (Marsh & Soulsby, 1987)....
8 Pages (2000 words) Case Study

To Live or Not To Live: The Terri Schiavo Debate

terri schiavo's condition was caused by a cardiac arrest.... The author examines the terri Schiavo case which became a household name in the debates over the right to die, as well as human rights.... nbsp; Many argue that it might have been, but then there were many arguments in this case.... While schiavo's state was considered irreversible, there is much more that may have been learned from her had she survived.... nbsp;… The incident that put terri in this predicament also must be called into question....
9 Pages (2250 words) Case Study

The Terri Schiavo

The paper “the terri Schiavo” discusses the terri Schiavo Case, which brought forth pertinent questions of law in regard to disabled people as well as those on life support.... The biggest conflict which came into being was also regarding the case being a right to die case or the disability rights case!... The reason why this was done was that it was felt by the Senate and the House of Representatives who had passed the Bill that the matter involved terri's Constitutional rights....
2 Pages (500 words) Case Study

Legal Scenario: Bistrot Pierre Case

This case study "Legal Scenario: Bistrot Pierre case" studies the judicial arguments made by the business.... In this case, the contractual relations between Buildrite and Bistrot created the rights and obligations for both parties – for Buildrite to build the extension by November 15 and for Bistrot to pay the price agreed upon.... In the above case, the parties agreed on the terms of the contract, and nowhere in the contract does it indicate that Bistrot will cover the additional costs for the renovation....
7 Pages (1750 words) Case Study

Analysis of Terri Schiavo Case

In all these cases, the courts viewed the freedom and privacy interest of the patients as supreme and thus, the judge argued that she would not have wished to continue living under life-prolonging measures all her life hence sanctioned the that the feeding tube be remove from her (Perry, Churchill and Kirshner, 2005) A number of legal considerations were put into perspective in the determination of this case.... This case spurred controversy in the legal, medical, ethical, political and social domains....
5 Pages (1250 words) Case Study

An Individuals Right to Refuse Medical Care

The paper “terri schiavo's case - One's Right to Refuse Medical Care, Ethical Issues, Health Policy Issues" is a breathtaking example of a case study on health sciences & medicine.... One con from one of the parties—in Michael schiavo's case—would be that he would have to continue to care for his disabled wife.... In this piece, the following elements will be analyzed: the historical perspective (including a brief history of the Schiavo case through the judicial system and the legislature); a brief discussion on an individual's right to refuse medical care; and the moral and ethical issues present in the case....
3 Pages (750 words) Case Study

The Doctrine of Consideration

This case study "The Doctrine of Consideration" focuses on the idea of legal value in relation to contracts.... hellip; The case of William v Roffey provides a perfect understanding and analysis of the English law and the way it is practiced with respect to the concept of consideration in contracts and agreements.... In this case, the same is the commands in the doctrine over legal thoughts that the courts have been equally prepared in many instances to develop consideration where it is conspicuously missing instead of questioning its importance....
7 Pages (1750 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us