StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Corporal Punishment - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
In the paper “Corporal Punishment” the author analyzes the moral dimension of corporal punishment, which requires much more than just recognition of the substantive doctrine of law. Since ancient times, corporal punishment was one of the most popular types of punishment and upbringing…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92% of users find it useful
Corporal Punishment
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Corporal Punishment"

Corporal punishment should be prohibited because violence breeds violence. The message that violence is a way to solve problems is surely not lost on children. Parents who were beaten as children end up beating their own children. Teachers who attended schools in which corporal punishment was an accepted practice may in a like manner find it natural to turn to it themselves, although other people, beaten as children, react adversely to the notion of using physical force themselves (Straus and Donnelley 2004).

Critics (Straus and Donnelley 2004) explain that the parents of children who are victims of the "battered child syndrome" are mentally ill. While corporal punishment applied by teachers is usually not so extreme in intent or result as the abuse inflicted on children by their own parents, its use by teachers who experienced corporal punishment as children suggests a tendency to "identify with the aggressor" which characterizes the authoritarian personality The use of force on children stems from an inherent cultural belief that violence is an acceptable way to solve problems.

Carried far enough, that position could suggest that the society itself is "mentally ill," judged by its approach to violence (Straus and Donnelley 2004). Corporal punishment is ineffective because it has an extremely negative impact on learning and child development. Prom the psychological point of view, to be effective in the long run, however, corporal punishment must be extremely harsh and repeated -- and even then the research results are inconclusive. The usual result of corporate punishment is "traumatic avoidance learning" (Straus and Donnelley 2004).

Critics (Straus and Donnelley 2004) underline that it is sometimes necessary to spank a two-year-old to keep the child from wandering into the street. That is the theory, and it may be effective for the short term. The spankings will have to become more frequent and severe as the child grows older and develops more complex reasons for crossing the street if the physical force is to be the primary educational tool. "Being hit is in no way teaches anything about the dangers nor will it prevent them from dangerous situations" (Pro-Corporal Punishment Answers 2001).

It is likely to be more effective in the long run to teach the child the danger he faces in heedlessly crossing the street and present him with a viable alternative, such as learning to look both ways. There is evidence that suspensions and corporal punishment are used most frequently against a select group of children The children in this group are often emotionally disturbed, black, Hispanic, or otherwise disadvantaged: they represent a "discipline problem." corporal punishment tends to reinforce their alienation from the white middle-class system of learning into which they had been thrust.

Because of corporal punishment, low-class children tend to feel they have little power to control their own destinies, then the attitudes of teachers and their approach to discipline can seriously affect the children's abilities to improve themselves and their situation. Lower-class children, who are paddled most frequently among schoolchildren, are likely to continue the behavior corporal punishment was meant to eliminate (Kennedy 2007). These facts suggest that corporal punishment is ineffective because it does not help teachers and parents to achieve the desires results.

As the most important, it has a negative impact on a child, his learning and personal development, and psychological state. There is a need to introduce special programs to educate teachers, parents, and school administrators about the harmful impact of corporal punishment on the behavior and achievement of children. References1. Pro-Corporal Punishment Answers (2001). 

Beating the Devil Out of Them: Corporal Punishment in American Families. Lexington Books. Pros 1. it a source of maintaining order 2. It is possible to use it if nothing else works3. it gives fast results and obedience of a child 4. It is an easy tool for a teacher (in contrast to discussions and explanations).5. 'The Bible admonishes us to us the 'rod' on children' (Pro-Corporal Punishment Answers 2001). Cons 1. It has a negative and damaging psychological impact on a child 2. It has a negative impact on learning and development 3.

Racial profiling and discrimination are possible (used against low-class children)4. It causes physical injuries and traumas 5. It is an Ineffective tool because it does not explain the causes and effects of wrong behavior and actions.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Corporal Punishment Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words, n.d.)
Corporal Punishment Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words. https://studentshare.org/human-resources/1533926-corporal-punishment
(Corporal Punishment Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
Corporal Punishment Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words. https://studentshare.org/human-resources/1533926-corporal-punishment.
“Corporal Punishment Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”. https://studentshare.org/human-resources/1533926-corporal-punishment.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Corporal Punishment

Should the U.S. reinstitute corporal punishment

Should the US reinstitute Corporal Punishment?... According to the UNESCO (2005) publication, any Corporal Punishment is prohibited with respect to human rights.... Thus, for me, I am against the reinstitution of the Corporal Punishment.... In Europe, any form of Corporal Punishment is abolished.... Should the US reinstitute Corporal Punishment?... According to the UNESCO (2005) publication, any Corporal Punishment is prohibited with respect to human rights....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Ban on Corporal Punishment on School

Name Tutor Course Date Ban on Corporal Punishment on school Many individuals still take Corporal Punishment as a way of effectively teaching the children.... Consequently, the argue may come on both sides, that is, either in support of the Corporal Punishment ban, or against the ban of Corporal Punishment as below.... hellip; Ultimately, long ago, Corporal Punishment did come in administration normally and no one could complain....
6 Pages (1500 words) Research Paper

Issues of Corporal Punishment

Corporal Punishment [University] [Instructor Name] Corporal Punishment Introduction The word Corporal Punishment is derived from the Latin word called corpus which even means body.... Corporal Punishment refers to the physical or bodily coercion that leads to trauma or defecting of the physical being.... hellip; In Corporal Punishment an individual is subjected to physical infliction of pain by the court of law....
6 Pages (1500 words) Research Paper

Corporal Punishment in School

Corporal Punishment in school: This essay is primarily based on discussing the issue of whether Corporal Punishment should be legalized, introduced, or justified in all schools around the globe or not.... Corporal Punishment is basically about deliberate infliction of pain on the students by the supervisors or teachers in response to any offensive action taken by them as a way of restraining bad behavior.... Facts and discussion presented in this essay are basically meant to illuminate the reality of the claim that “Corporal Punishment could be seriously bad for the mental and moral wellbeing of the students which is why it should not be allowed to be introduced in the schools as a way of coping mechanism....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

State Laws on Corporal Punishment

The study aims at investigating some of the key factors that have facilitated in the intensive use of Corporal Punishment in America public schools despite of the existence of policy that bans employment of Corporal Punishment in public schools.... … The study will specifically rely on data that will be collected from all stakeholders involved in Corporal Punishment including students, government institutions, teachers, policy makers, parents, and school administrators....
9 Pages (2250 words) Research Paper

The Corporal Punishment Debate

This paper "The Corporal Punishment Debate" focuses on the fact that in the Philippines, a mom beat her son on the head with a broomstick after finding out that he had been stealing electric cables.... The sad truth is Corporal Punishment for children, although it may not be a humane way to discipline children, has long been recognized as a means to keep the young ones in line.... 2009) Corporal Punishment for children is not a new thing.... Since ancient times, Corporal Punishment on children has been recorded in literature, art and science....
11 Pages (2750 words) Case Study

Child discipline and corporal punishment

This essay "Child discipline and Corporal Punishment" dwells on the controversial issue of child Corporal Punishment.... Notably, in many countries like the USA, a certain degree of Corporal Punishment is punishable by law, and so a parent will rather try to avoid than do this.... One advantage of this is that the parent himself will not be held responsible for any act of Corporal Punishment that is in turn punishable by the law....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Is Corporal Punishment Needed to Discipline Children

This paper "Is Corporal Punishment Needed to Discipline Children?... will discuss whether Corporal Punishment is a necessary form of punishment, and highlight the issues surrounding the debate on this subject.... The research findings have served to highlight that Corporal Punishment is ineffective....   … Corporal Punishment denotes a form of correction defined by the use of physical force, triggering pain, and discomfort....
5 Pages (1250 words) Term Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us